For all that Sam's instincts are fucked, that was a good show of trust and goodwill.
Has anyone else noticed little props that seem to forshadow a characters prenence in an ep? In 6x01 there was a poster for DJ Sammy. In "You Can't Handle the Truth" in the dentist's office the name on the lamp was Castle or something (which always makes me think of Castiel) and I swear there was one other.
If there's anything that I'm lamenting this season, it's the downgrade in lighting, filming, and editing. I don't recall a season where I found any faults in the timing, placement, movement of the camera. One of those "you don't know how skilled it is until it's not", where you're not noticing the technique because it's doing it's job in telling a good story. "Family Matters" had more of the clumsy moments that struck me, where the beats were off in the cuts or something.
"The Third Man" and "Live Free or Twihard" both struck me as excellently directed and filmed (and edited, for the former), and while "Weekend at Bobby's" didn't have the same level of inventiveness I thought it was capably done. This last one is the only episode of the season I can recall looking amateurish, or being unclear about what's happening onscreen.
Was this one by a rookie director?
Guy Bee. He directed Asylum back in 2005.
What was amateurish to you, Matt and Julie? Nothing jumped out at me, but having just watched this week's Criminal Minds, I may be innoculated for dizzying crap visual storytelling for a while.
For the latest ep, what jumps to mind is the scene where Cas turns to stare out the window, and then the cut to him being gone. Even on the third rewatch, that felt awkward and clumsy. And of course the shots where Cas "cleans up" Sam.
And I'm not saying that the eps are chock full of film-school blunders every minute, they're not. But the one, three or five in a couple of eps far outweighs the almost perfect zero for the last five seasons.
I remember the episode with the baby being clumsy. Two and a Half Men. I only noticed when they ruined the Guttenberg line.
"Dean's into printing? Oh, they showed a baby, they meant Steve Guttenburg. Yeah, now it's not funny."
eta:
I just realized that this Sam would have poked the old lady with a stick where season two Sam was, "Dude! You're not gonna poke her with a stick!” He had more of a sense of right and wrong than Dean did back then.
I think the only episode comment I've posted on LJ was, "Dude. Sammy would SO poke her with a stick. And probably will."
I thought that the episode felt flat. I was thinking it was the writing - but perhaps it was the direction.
He had more of a sense of right and wrong than Dean did back then.
I think Dean has always had a solid sense of right and wrong. Just not always with the appropriateness. Poking her with a stick wouldn't have been morally wrong. It would have been incredibly rude though.
Heh. Poking an old lady with a stick is pretty wrong by any definition. I am laughing pretty hard that we are discussing this though. I offer this into evidence that SHOW has warped us.
