'Our Mrs. Reynolds'
[NAFDA]. This is where we talk about the CW series Supernatural! Anything that's aired in the US on TV (including promos) is fair game. No spoilers though — if you post one by accident, an admin will delete it.
this approach to damnation wouldn't be unheard-of.
But it doesn't gibe with the Godness in Show we've seen so far, if he's the one making the call. Joshua gave me the impression that it was Him that was making the decision to resurrect them each time they died, and that He was responsible for their sojourns in Heaven each time, not Zackie-pooh.
He was responsible for their sojourns in Heaven each time, not Zackie-pooh.
So you think Zachariah just horned in on their last trip, and decided to use it to his advantage?
So you think Zachariah just horned in on their last trip, and decided to use it to his advantage?
Yeah. You think Zach brought them to Heaven each time and wiped their memories?
You think Zach brought them to Heaven each time and wiped their memories?
No! But how many times were they there?
If Sam went during AHBL, then ... I don't know who would have wiped his memory, unless that was part of the package the demon offered.
When was Dean ever in heaven aside from Dark Side of the Moon?
The writers should have made a bible for these details and stuck with it, is what.
All those hundreds of times he died in Mystery Spot (the whiplash he must have gotten repeatedly pulling a U-y at the pearly gates!)?
But Mystery Spot was before his deal, which I always thought meant he would have gone to hell each time. Or just nowhere, since he wasn't really dead until the Wednesday.
I don't know!
Maybe he was in Gabrielimbo.
Gabrielimbo sounds like a really funky dance. I can see Sam and his bigass limbs flailing now.
When was Dean ever in heaven aside from Dark Side of the Moon?
Ash said they'd both been there before and he'd seen them, so there may have been offscreen deaths.
Oh, I forgot that part. I need to keep notes, I swear.