I forgot to record my rationale but the hardest choices were Bracket #1, choices 3 & 4

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #1/4:

Sam: drop the show and be my brother again

Sam: That's hellfire, Dean.

Dean: Don't objectify me.

Sam: I lost my shoe.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #2/4:

Young Dean: First thing you have to know is we have the coolest dad in the world. He's a superhero.

Bobby: Family don't end with blood, boy.

Bela: rolling naked in money.

Dean: You fudging touch me again I'll fudging kill you!

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #3/4:

Sam and Dean: Sam Winchester cries his way through sex.

Dean: I didn't deserve what he put on me and I don't deserve to go to Hell!

Agent Henricksen: Rest in peace, guys.

Sam: You peed yourself, Dean.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #4/4:

Sam: we're morons.

Ed Zeddmore: Get inside your duffel?

Trickster: You can't save your brother.

Sam: Just--bring him back. Please.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #1/4:

• I wish you would drop the show and be my brother again, 'cause... just 'cause.
• That's hellfire, Dean.
• Don't objectify me.
• I think it's 'cause we're so awesome.

• First thing you have to know is we have the coolest dad in the world. He's a superhero.
• Family don't end with blood, boy.
• I don't want to die. And I don't want to go to hell.
• I mean, I can't sit around drinking eggnog, celebrating Christmas, when I know next year, you'll be dead. I just can't.

• Sam Winchester keeps a ruler by the bed and every morning when he wakes up..... Okay, enough!
• I didn't deserve what he put on me and I don't deserve to go to Hell!
• Come on! You do this out of vengeance and obsession. You're a stone's throw from being a serial killer.
• I'm Batman.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #4/4:

• Uh, that we're morons.
• I don't know. I'd like to.
• You can't save your brother. No good comes out of it--just pain, and blood.
• Just--bring him back. Please.

There are more Sam quotes in this round that resonate for me than in previous seasons. Maybe they wrote for him differently? Or maybe because it's all about them working to save Dean, which means Sam's angsting, and I'm a sucker for brotherly angst.

(I have no regrets for my earlier vote. None.)

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #1/4:

• Be my brother again
  
• That's hellfire, Dean
  
• Don't objectify me.
  
• I lost my shoe
  

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #2/4:

• Superhero (oh, boys!)
  
• Family don't end with blood, boy
  
• We'll find a way to save you
  
• You fudging touch me again I'll fudging kill you!
  

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #3/4:

• Sam and Dean in unison (too funny)
  
• He's the one who let mom die! (ouch)
  
• Rest in peace, guys. (damn, I miss Henricksen)
  
• Man gets hit by a car you think he has control of his bladder? Come on!
  

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #4/4:

• We're morons
  
• Do you believe in God, Dean (mostly for the ironic-in-retrospect answer)
  
• You can't save your brother. No good comes out of it--just pain, and blood.
  
• Just--bring him back. Please

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #1/4

Sam: Yeah, because I've been following you around my entire life. I mean, I've been looking up to you since I was four, Dean. Studying you, trying to be just like my big brother.So, yeah, I know you. Better than anyone else in the entire world. And this is exactly how you act when you're terrified. And, I mean, I can't blame you. It's just...

Dean: What?

Sam: It's just, I wish you would drop the show and be my brother again, 'cause... just 'cause. -- One, it's a good quote. Two, Bela shot Sam and didn't die? Right.

Dean: All I see is the light at the end of the tunnel.

Sam: That's hellfire, Dean. -- Huh, S3, still not my favorite. But hi, Sammy, hi.

Ruby: Does anyone have a breath mint? Some guts splattered into my mouth while I was killing my way in here. -- Okay, Ruby beats Bela. Original flavor Ruby beats recycling Ruby. Ruby either wanting french fries or a breath mint to mask demon guts? Kinda funny.

Sam: I lost my shoe. -- I still have this as an lj icon. The antichrist lost his shoe.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #2/4 Young Dean: First thing you have to know is we have the coolest dad in the world. He's a superhero. -- Young Dean needs some therapy.

Bobby: Family don't end with blood, boy. -- Yay Bobby!

Dean: I don't want to die. And I don't want to go to hell.
Sam: Then we'll find a way to save you.
Dean: Okay, good. -- Winchesters? Taking forever to state the obvious since 2005.

Sam: I mean, I can't sit around drinking eggnog, celebrating Christmas, when I know next year, you'll be dead. I just can't. -- Awww, Winchester Christmas...

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #3/4

Sam and Dean: (In unison): Right, you're a mind reader. Cut it out, Sam... Sam! You think you're funny but you're being really, really childish! - Sam Winchester wears makeup. Sam Winchester cries his way through sex. Sam Winchester keeps a ruler by the bed and every morning when he wakes up..... Okay, enough! -- I just like synchronized stuff.

Dean: He's the one who let mom die! Who wasn't there for Sam, I always was! It wasn't fair! I didn't deserve what he put on me and I don't deserve to go to Hell! -- He's not wrong...

Agent Henricksen: Sam and Dean Winchester were in the chopper when it caught on fire. Nothing's left. Can't even identify 'em with dental records. Rest in peace, guys. -- Henricksen! Just cause he was cool.

Dean: I'm Batman. -- This vote? I mean it. A lot.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #4/4

Dean: What'd Bobby say? 
Sam: Uh, that we're morons. -- This one was hard. It was quintessential Bobby awesomeness or the mission statement for S3. Except this mission statement sort of sucked and, as much as it's started grating on me with overuse, Bobby dissing the boys should be idjits. So coin toss.

Casey: Do you believe in god, Dean? I'd be surprised if you did.

Dean: I don't know. I'd like to. -- Poor Dean. He wants to believe. Bet he regrets that now.

Trickster: You can't save your brother. No good comes out of it--just pain, and blood. -- I liked Loki before he was Gabe.

Sam: Just--bring him back. Please. -- Poor Sammikins.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #1/4:
I wish you would drop the show and be my brother again, 'cause... just 'cause.
That's hellfire, Dean.
Does anyone have a breath mint? (though really I'm not crazy about either quote)
I lost my shoe.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #2/4:
A Hand of Glory?
Family don't end with blood, boy.
Okay, good.
I just can't.

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #3/4:
Okay, enough!
I don't deserve to go to Hell!
You're a stone's throw from being a serial killer.
I'm Batman

Season 3, Round 1, Bracket #4/4:
Dean: What do you say we kill some evil sons of bitches and raise a little hell?
I don't know. I'd like to.
No good comes out of it--just pain, and blood.
Just--bring him back. Please.

Season 3 1/4
be my brother
That's hellfire, Dean
Don't objectify me.
I lost my shoe.

Season 3 2/4
Okay enough!
I don't deserve to go to Hell!
You're a stone's throw from being a serial killer!
Well, of course I peed myself

Season 3 4/4
Young Dean: He's a superhero
Bobby: Family don't end with blood, boy.
Sam: Then we'll find a way to save you.
Sam:I mean, I can't sit around drinking eggnog, celebrating Christmas, when I know next year, you'll be dead. I just can't.

Season 3 4/4
Dean: What do you say we kill some evil sons of bitches and raise a little hell?
Casey: Do you believe in god, Dean? I'd be surprised if you did.
Dean: I don't know. I'd like to. (I'm wondering if this seems more significant now then it did at first watch.)
Trickster: You can't save your brother. No good comes out of it - - just pain, and blood.
Sam: Man, I had a weird dream.
Dean: Yeah? Clowns or midgets?

Awww, a show on Roanoke. I'm explaining to them (yes, they are on the tv) about Croatoan. With liberal lashings of SPN. Some days I make my own fun.