It seems like the problem may be that there's a whole lot of nothing in between the choice between giving them up or getting no help for them at all.
Several years ago in NJ two teenagers killed a pizza delivery man in what was described as a "thrill kill". My Mom worked a counseling agency in the county where it happened. One of the kids' Mother had been trying to get help for him for YEARS. Literall, frantically, desperately telling anyone who would listen that he was going to do something terrible if they couldn't get him some help. Can you imagine knowing that about your 14 year old boy, fighting for years, and then being right? It was a horror.
And there may be parents using Nebraska as a dumping area for kids that they just don't want to raise anymore. But if someone's willing to drive from another state to get rid of their kid, I don't know how great it would be for the kid to be raised by them. Being raised by someone who considers kids a burden can suck even if they are willing to stick it out.
At least they drive them to Nebraska. That's a step above the parents who just walk out on their kids. So many "runaways" are really throwaways.
Noah also got to ride a trike on the trike track. So cute. Until he exhausted himself into sleep.
At which point he was MIND NUMBINGLY cute?
As bad as they could be, orphanages really can serve a purpose and I hate that our society just stopped them altogether and have so few things around like the Methodist homes and Boys ranches.
We (and I'm not sure if that's "Americans" or "humans") have a nasty habit of discarding something wholesale when it has problems. When the "primarily residence home" model for every child abandoned by or yanked from their parents (often for reasons we'd now be appalled by) had serious problems we dropped it completely in favor of what evolved into foster-care -- which was never big enough from the start. Then they sort of accidentally created group homes (which were anemic temporary boys homes) and never made enough of them. Now we have a situation where in many states if a ward of the state can't be accomodated (often teenagers)they get sent to juvenile detention until a spot can be found. So if you're a homeless kid you get sent to jail. Very very Oliver Twist work house, you know?
The idea behind getting rid of the big mental institutions and orphanages, which had too often served as not much more than warehouses, was that they would be replaced by community-based facilities. They did the first part, but never got around to the second. Homelessness and a highly dysfunctional foster system are not really an improvement.
Yeah, that.