I watched the new S&S and I didn't get the impression that Marianne had slept with Willoughby or caught a disease from him.

I miss the Deli Haus. I was just in Kenmore the other night bemoaning all the swankery, missing the Deli Haus.

Awww! Deli Haus!!! I spent A LOT of time there as an undergrad.

Our high school hangout was the Charcoal Pit. Milkshakes and fries and big bowls of pickles! And then they kicked us out and we moved across the parking lot to hang out outside the Punkin Donuts. I took this picture:

[link]

But, yeah, if they implied that Marianne slept with Willoughby, that would be a breathtaking liberty.

I really don't think they did imply that. The shocking part was that she went to his aunt's house with him totally unchaperoned. Which was in the book, right?

There was petting! They showed them petting at the aunt's house.

Wow. Er, how are you defining petting?

For that matter, I'm not sure how anybody defines petting. It's always been shrouded in mystery for me.

(In reference to humans, that is.)

OH! I saw just a bit of S&S and I saw that bit and I did not think they had the sex or that it was implied.

There was petting! They showed them petting at the aunt's house.

Well, their hands brushed each against each others and there was that one kiss.

...

What is "petting" anyway? I always imagined as a kid that it was stroking your beloveds hair.

I remember them barely kissing, but it's been a couple of months since I saw that version.

As for the illness, I think the implication is that Marianne either a) basically works herself into a state over Willoughby or b) is so worked up that she displays no judgment at all and exhausts herself while walking in the rain. Her whole illness is the last hurrah of her being the one with "sensibility", as opposed to sense.

Well, they definitely made it to first base, and they showed him unfastening pieces of her clothing, so he had rounded first base and was headed to second before they cut away.

b) is so worked up that she displays no judgment at all and exhausts herself while walking in the rain.

This is what I thought as well. And that the exhaustion lowered her immune system and she caught the virus or whatever that made her dangerously ill.

She gets chilled from walking in the rain in a state of mental anguish. . . or something.

I couldn't believe that they had Brandon carry her all the way from the carriage across the threshold in their final scene. Was that just to prove what a manly man he is?