Okay, yeah. Crochet by its nature closes the yarn over almost immediately. I could see where having a big loose spot on the needle would be problematic. Other than that, I think I only understood about 1/3 of what you & Sophia said - did I mention the most complicated thing I've ever knit was a scarf?

I never thought I could knit! And now I'm doing this. The other project I want to start is learn cables, I have some yarn in my yarn stash I'm going to use for the project.

Has anyone done needlepunch? My yarn shop is going to be adding needlepunch and doing a class it kind of looks like fun and looks easier than cross stitch or embroiderery.

The thing that YO does that other increases don't is give you that lacy, open look. So that row with eyelet holes won't have the eyelet holes. I leave it to you to decide whether this is a bug or a feature.

Has anyone done needlepunch? My yarn shop is going to be adding needlepunch and doing a class it kind of looks like fun and looks easier than cross stitch or embroiderery.

I've never tried, but my neighbor showed me hers a million years ago. She was making the poodle applique for a 50's-style circle skirt for her daughter. Looked easy enough - I always just worried I'd get impatient and space out the spaces too much. Hopefully the tool has a way to correct for that.

The yarn store where I bought the yarn for my next project (OMG, never bought 14 skeins at once before - painful!) is doing a weaving class soon. I'm so tempted, but the practicalities of Where The Hell Would I Put A Flippin' Loom In My Tiny Cluttered House? are holding me back.

Needlepunch seems much more self-contained and small-space-friendly. :)

eta context

I kept thinking I had seen something like needle punch on tv so I googled and there was an infomercial for Purr fect Punch on the Amazing Discoveries Infomercial "series" (they did the sweater machine) but the only video I can find is dubbed in German.

I tried 2D needlefelting and didn't really get it. Or maybe it was the teacher, there's a new instructor and I may sign up for one of those classes.

Is needle punch the same thing as needle felting?

The yarn-overs that give me problems are purl-wise ones.

No. Needlefelting is done with roving and you punch it into felt either as 2D or you work it in a 3d object. And there's wet needlefelting.

Here's some 3D needlefelted items - [link]

Needlepunch is kind more like a needlepoint, you use a punch tool to make loops through the material and it creates this kind of effect [link]

So needlepunching is basically rug-hooking? My mom did this in the 70's, and I did learn to do it as a kid. It was pretty fun! She actually did hooked stair tread rugs from drawings that each person in my family did, and then never put them on the stairs!

My project is at standstill. I'm untangling yarn. I pulled from the center and there were two huge globs of yarn vomit. Katy (the owner of the yarn shop) worked for an hour and a half trying to untangle it. I've worked on it for about 2 hours. It's still not done.

It would have been faster to unravel the project and start over at the other end ....but the yarn isn't cheap and it shouldn't be like this. I just sent an email to the company letting them know this was a first purchase and very disappointing.

Yeah, that's why I never pull from the center.