But aren't we all mashups? Of our parents, our friends, our experiences?
My mom's -- or anyone's -- personality isn't overlaid on my empty one. I can't say "Because I know P-C, I can therefore be a kickass medical writer and Mikado filker." (I wish.) Knowing someone doesn't make me them.
Yeah, my argument is based on the idea that the Dollhouse brain-tech would actually work, instead of being an effective lobotomy (which is basically is, now that I think about it), so this is sort of a silly argument.
Well, there's some of that, and there's also the chemical soup that makes us who we are. For example, erasing my memory would not erase the seratonin imbalance that makes me depressed, which heavily influences my personality, decision making skills, and hair trigger temper. I'd be imprinted with memories, but add to that the mental illness, and you'd still have a mashup.
This would also follow with someone with autism, or schizophrenia.
There seems a weird confusion on the show between expertise granted by a memory program (like Tank loading up the program to operate a helicopter in The Matrix)and physiological issues (like asthma). You can load me with a hundred memories from the brain of an autistic man with prostrate cancer, but it doesn't change teh fact that I'm not autistic and don't have a prostrate, so neither my brain nor my body will experience the world with a cancerous bum or an autistic mind.
Does anyone have the line the lab tech used to explain the shortsightedness?
Does anyone have the line the lab tech used to explain the shortsightedness?
Handwave, handwave, the brain perceives the world as though she were nearsighted, handwave, handwave, midichlorians.
I was kinda wanting to poke holes in the verbatim.
I think Amy was an Actives, and then imprinted with being a doc. It is what popped in my head when I saw a doc with scars. Can you believe it took a moment for me to realize it was Amy?? After all the swooning during Angel!
ita, it may be up on Hulu or Fox.com by now.
Here is the quote:
"she is nearsighted"...
"I can mess up the neural connections to her eyesight. Make her brain process the information it gets any way I want."
Topher: "I can mess up the neural connections to her eyesight. Mske her brain process the information it gets any way I want. As for example, blurry."
Weaker than I'd thought. I'd buy an imprint fucking with the CNS or altering brain chemistry, but that's not what they said.
Handwave, handwave, the brain perceives the world as though she were nearsighted, handwave, handwave, midichlorians.
I did not see the show, but I am
weeping
with laughter.
Fucking midichlorians.