'Objects In Space'
A topic for the discussion of Doctor Who, Arrow, and The Flash. Beware possible invasions of iZombie, Sleepy Hollow, or pretty much any other "genre" (read: sci fi, superhero, or fantasy) show that captures our fancy. Expect adult content and discussion of the Big Gay Sex.
Marvel superheroes are discussed over at the MCU thread.
Whitefont all unaired in the U.S. ep discussion, identifying it as such, and including the show and ep title in blackfont.
Blackfont is allowed after the show has aired on the east coast.
This is NOT a general TV discussion thread.
Maybe a time travel plot where nobody falls in love at all?
I thought that was a cardinal rule of time travel in general - you will meet your one great love. Or one of your great loves. In any case, you will have to leave him or her behind. Or it, if we're in sci-fi mode.
Anyway, it's why I hesitate to try it. Who needs that kind of heart break?
Motherfuck! No new Chuck expected till fall either.
I like Chuck, but a little Chuck goes a long way.
I'm with Scola. I also got really tired with the guy-ness of it all. There's only so many times I need to see the love interest in her skivvies, or the two idiots at the Buy More harassing female customers.
What, Torchwood 19mumble couldn't have kept him from going back to the front? Like, a "top secret but crucial service to our country" kind of discharge? That sucks!
Well, past!Torchwood wouldn't have known what happened to him when he got sent to the front. There was no reason to keep him at the hospital. Once they found out, they could have amended the orders at that point not to send him back, but that would be messing with the time stream, and that's a no no. Plus, they don't know if there was something about Tommy that would make it happen again.
Plus, they don't know if there was something about Tommy that would make it happen again.
I want to think that Tommy's experiences with Torchwood (and he didn't have his memories erased!) may have created a wild card effect. His experiences there affect how he reacts once he's back in 1918. And maybe he did something different after he went back.
I think there's a fatal flaw in that line of reasoning, which is that Tommy didn't live linearly. That Tommy-after-he-went-back always had memories of Torchwood.
Which actually raises another question: How much effect did Tosh's answers to his questions have on what he did after he went back? She left him thinking he'd die in battle. Did he try to avoid that?
I think there's a fatal flaw in that line of reasoning, which is that Tommy didn't live linearly. That Tommy-after-he-went-back always had memories of Torchwood.
But he didn't remember. He didn't remember what to do with the key thingy and he didn't know who Tosh was.
Which was weird, since (after what Jack said) I was expecting Past Torchwood to DO something to his memories -- instead, they seemed to just get replaced automatically once he stepped through the barrier.
She left him thinking he'd die in battle. Did he try to avoid that?
perhaps that's what caused the court marshal. He thought that he was going to die in battle, so he tried to avoid it, and got dinged for cowardice.
But he didn't remember. He didn't remember what to do with the key thingy and he didn't know who Tosh was.
Jack said something about losing his short term memory in the rift.
instead, they seemed to just get replaced automatically once he stepped through the barrier.
Maybe because he was in the right time, and he had technically never lived through the 20th century?
Ow. That makes my head hurt. Especially since the real reason is probably "He forgot because we needed him to."
Jack's line about the British soldiers who were shot for cowardice is really painful, though.