Sister dear, look 4 posts above you.

ETA: Yeah, you looked.

Happy birthday, Sumi!

I've been sailing through Blogger's "next blog" feature, and because I'm that girl, flagging the inappropriate ones.

Happy Birthday, sumi!

I am unfocused and craving food that is not readily available in my house.

OTOH, mac choose a righteously nasty day to have his fever, so thank dog I don't have to be out in it.

I think it is more the attitude of "I'm going to vote for someone who shares my values" rather than "I'm not going to vote for a Jew". Maybe it boils down to the same thing, but the first one sounds more reasonable. I think the crazy part is the assumption of a direct correlation between religious affiliation and values.

I don't care if I vote for someone who worships Satan in his/her personal life. You really just kind of have to take someone's word for what they believe.

Now, do his/her actions match up with my ideals of equal rights for everybody, fair wages, fair housing etc. Other than that be a member of Church What Thinks We All Were Barfed Up In A Giant Kitty's Hairball.

Happy Birthday Sumi!

I am still hungry and I have eaten all my food. Also, I forgot my wallet this morning and have to meet my old co-workers for drinks after work. Le Sigh.

In my experience, part of the "Not a real Christian" thing comes from an ethos where people are Christians or they are Not Christians. There are only two choices. So its less an analysis of the specific expression of faith than a "are they us or them" sort of thing. And Not Christians are pretty much all the same as one another cred-wise. (and that cred can vary wildly among the assessor) In that dichotomy a Catholic, a Mormon, a Jew, a Muslim, a Wicca or even a Presbyterian such as myself who believes in ::gasp:: evolution is in the Not Christian category.

(Eventually I got used to being described as "not really a Christian" by some of my more country classmates. Its like Jews who go to Utah and find out that they're Gentiles.)

What always cracked me up the phenomenon that saying someone is a "Good Christian" is tantamount to saying they are a good person. Like, even if they aren't actually a Christian. "I like Dr. Greenberg, he's a good Christian" is a perfectly cromulent thing to say.

Its like Jews who go to Utah and find out that they're Gentiles.

No, YOU'RE a gentile! No, YOU are!

The only people who get to claim that Catholics aren't Christian are the Eastern Orthodox, and that's more of a "Mooooooom! She's touching me!!" type of issue.

Ah-ha-ha! This is a lovely variation on how the Orthodox priest who married my parents described it; he described the two as identical twin sisters who got in an incredibly petty fight ages ago, neither one would back down, and they haven't spoken since -- although they still look and dress and talk alike and have all the same friends. They're still bent out of shape over the original fight, and everyone who knows both of them is all, "Okay, whatever, you're completely different and YOU are SO RIGHT" while @@ing like crazy behind both their backs.

But I think he'd like "Mooooooom! She's touching me!!" even better.