I didn't like dolls, but I had an elaborate collection of Breyer horses that I invented all sorts of dramatic scenarios for. They were usually either mustangs living wild and free, Talking Horses of Narnia, or, you know, Talking Mustangs of Wyoming, living wild and free.
Annabel isn't that into dolls so far, either, but can get elaborate games going with her stuffed animals. Her favorites are a complete set of Backyardigans beanie babies, with whom she acts out scenarios from the show, occasionally interspersed with her own inventions, such as "Backyardigans go to watch the baseball-Mariners, and then go to school the next day."
Oh, and ever since I mentioned that Tyrone on Backyardigans was a moose like the Mariner moose, she says Tyrone is going to be a baseball moose when he gets big.
Today DH tried to get her to wear a new shirt with an applique-type picture of a fawn on the front, and she refused. When they got to daycare, her friend Maya was wearing that shirt, leading us to wonder if the girls are somehow sending psychic signals to each other to avoid being dressed alike...