Got to be. While I understand the concept behind not wanting exes at your wedding, I think there's a difference when that person has been part of the new couple's life. I mean, Robin has hung out at Stella's house.

BTW, these VW commercials with Brooke Shields are ridiculous and stupid.

BTW, these VW commercials with Brooke Shields are ridiculous and stupid.

Oh, god, couldn't agree more.

these VW commercials with Brooke Shields are ridiculous and stupid.

they crack me up! I'm pretty easy I guess.

While I understand the concept behind not wanting exes at your wedding, I think there's a difference when that person has been part of the new couple's life. I mean, Robin has hung out at Stella's house.

I thought they were working a typical sitcom thing where an unnecessary complication was arising from the Bride being Crazy but then they turned it around.

I guess that it was more about Stella's unresolved issues that Ted's. also, side note: where is Lucy. Stella and Lucy's dad were on the ferry, so where was the kid?

Oh! I thought that in the beginning of their relationship Stella had said that Lucy's dad was totally out of the picture. Did I make that up?

No, she said that. But, when you have a kid with someone, they can only be out of the picture but so much.

But, when you have a kid with someone, they can only be out of the picture but so much.

I don't think that's necessarily true. He could have been a one-night stand or married or just didn't want to be part of their lives at all. I thought it might be a ret-con and I'm sad that it is. This show is usually so good with the continuity!

I love the VW commercials too, lisah.

But, when you have a kid with someone, they can only be out of the picture but so much.

I don't think that's necessarily true. He could have been a one-night stand or married or just didn't want to be part of their lives at all. I thought it might be a ret-con and I'm sad that it is. This show is usually so good with the continuity!

I'm not really looking at it as a retcon, or I guess it's hand-wavable, particularly after last night's episode. Stella had (has) big-time Tony issues, so I can see her telling someone else that he's completely out of the picture, in an effort to convince herself that he's completely out of the picture.

I really loved that episode. A lot.

I really loved that episode. A lot.

I loved it too.

Stella had (has) big-time Tony issues, so I can see her telling someone else that he's completely out of the picture, in an effort to convince herself that he's completely out of the picture.

I could buy this but the first time we see Tony w/ Ted it's obvious that they've met and had some sort of relationship before. And, as far as I remember, that hasn't been mentioned previously at all.

That's a good point, but a lot of Ted and Stella's relationship has taken place off screen, so I'm still okay with it.

I am going to miss Sarah Chalke. I'm mostly glad she's not the mother, but I really enjoyed her turn as Stella.