can someone just make up a chart at this point?
No, but here's a list. I was thinking about waiting until the next round, but since you predicted that joke...
Cilantro Yay/Grapefruit Yay
  Liese S.
  lisah (rr)
  Kat
  Bobbi 
  SuziQ 
  sumi 
  Hil R (rr, p)
  ND 
  megan walker
  KristinT
  Aimee
  Tom Scola 
  Nora Deirdre
  Laura 
  beth b 
  Megan E
  JZ (rr) 
  P.M. Marcontell
  Lee 
  Laga 
Cilantro Boo/Grapefruit Boo
  JenP 
  billytea 
  Zenkitty 
Cilantro Yay/Grapefruit Boo
  Susan W. 
  amych 
  Chikat 
  ita 
  MFNlaw
  Theodosia
  Sue 
  Daisy Jane 
  Vortex 
Cilantro Boo/Grapefruit Yay
  DavidS (rr) 
  meara (rr) 
  brenda m (gf juice)
  Toddson 
Cilantro Yay/Grapefruit ?
  Cash
  Jessica 
  Nilly 
  Jesse 
Cilantro Boo/Grapefruit ?
Grapefruit Yay/Cilantro?
  Laga
  MM 
  Laura 
Grapefruit Boo/Cilantro?
  Kathy A 
  Ailleann
 
Oh - rr after grapefruit means and expressed preference for ruby red.
Y'all didn't think I was going to do it, did you?