This is how I think it should have worked. The biggest argument against it though, is that the Teddy Bear's head was still all ripped in the back (and had red tape across the gunshot exit wound).
And Audrey's parents had that sunburn you get when you wear your sunglasses at the beach. Red face, white eyes. I didn't catch that when I was looking at the bear. So they really went to Bali and it had lasting effects.
I hope Sam didn't keep the coin, but I agree that it is not beyond him. I didn't like the line about not going back, not being the same man. I mean, I know it is happening, but seeing him actually harden is almost too much.
eta: I'm still grieving for Jess even if he isn't.
I kid you not. I heard on the radio that there is a preacher man coming to town that claims to heal people. He's (or his corporation is) renting one of the halls at a local hotel.
Dude, I gotta go and see if I see any reapers.
ION, when Dean told Sam to make that wish to go back, why hadn't he already thrown a coin in the well, and keeping in mind that wishes have to be carefully planned to avoid any suicidal teddy bears, said very specifically, "I want time to go back to Nov 1st, 1983. I don't want Sammy or myself to remember anything. I should however, have the compulsion to tell my mother, the monster hunter, that a man with yellow eyes is coming to the house tomorrow night." That way Mary has time to decide on fight or flight.
I thought the coin got melted down. One of the boys said it was, don't remember which one. I think they're smart enough to realize any wish they try to outthink is still going to come back and bite them in the ass.
Sam said it, but we didn't see it happen.
Sam didn't even want to make a wish when Dean asked him to. i doubt very much he hung onto the coin.
Someone on my flist is catching up on SPN, and she recently watched "Jus in Bello" and was really upset about Victor's death. This is what she said:
(Seriously, Victor is not dead. Or he will at least come back as a helpful-but-sarcastic ghost. Right?)
Hilarious!
It's really too bad that the boys don't have a Dennis.
Sam didn't even want to make a wish when Dean asked him to. i doubt very much he hung onto the coin.
I would have said this too, but after this episode and the "I'm not the same man" line, I don't know who Sam is anymore. It's been a little upsetting actually because I don't have a handle on a character who I thought I understood. Not upsetting in a I-can't-go-to-work-tomorrow way, but just unsettling.
I think they're smart enough to realize any wish they try to outthink is still going to come back and bite them in the ass.
Sam was- I think. At the time, I think Dean was seriously suggesting Sam try it.
I spent a good chunk of the weekend rewatching S1. One of the things I noted was Meg's clothing, since the comment about her "dressing like a slut" in the current season. There was a scene with her shirt off one shoulder, showing a sexy black bra strap, shots of short shirts that showed skin above her pants and then there was the scene where she was in just her bra in the window, knowing that Sam was watching her from the car.
I had forgotten those bits and had just remembered jeans and a leather jacket for most of her scenes.
