Oh yeah, I'd love the HP stuff to go into the book club thread.
I agree with the cowgirl.
'Heart Of Gold'
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: Jon B, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych, msbelle, shrift, Dana, Laura
Stompy Emerita: ita, DXMachina
Oh yeah, I'd love the HP stuff to go into the book club thread.
I agree with the cowgirl.
Stompies? Can we just reopen the book thread then? I think we have a full on consense.
Can we open it today?
Why? I think pre-book discussion has been co-existing fine with other discussion in Literary, so far.
Well, since we've bullshit consensed on a decision, I see no reason why not to implement that decision immediately. Especially since it's been asked for multiple times from the Stompies at this point.
Also, as noted in Literary, the book is already both on teh intarwebs and in some rare cases on the ground. I think a bit early is better than a bit late.
Also, as noted in Literary, the book is already both on teh intarwebs and in some rare cases on the ground. I think a bit early is better than a bit late.
And you think there will be a consensus to allow spoilers in the thread? I would rather open the thread Friday night.
I think there's a need, and opening a spoily thread now fills that need. I don't think anybody will want to go full monty in Literary, because we are respectful hedgehogs, but that doesn't mean people don't want to go full monty.
(The first realio trulio spoiler-talk location I've seen was put up midday yesterday, and it appears to have quite a few discussers. Who have moved past the "rocks fall! Everybody dies!" jokey stage of spoilydom. The same could easily happen here, no?)
we are respectful hedgehogs
I love this clause and want to marry it.
I've seen people reacting to the spoilers, which is nearly as bad, and then I have to try to run away and close my eyes at the same time.
I've seen people reacting to the spoilers, which is nearly as bad, and then I have to try to run away and close my eyes at the same time.
Yes! This. (and the running blind thing is very dangerous!)