I get confused. I remember everything. I remember too much, and... some of it's made up, and... some of it can't be quantified, and... there's secrets.

River ,'Safe'


Non-Fiction TV: I Reject Your Reality and Substitute My Own

This thread is for non-fiction TV, including but not limited to reality television (So You Think You Can Dance, Top Chef: Masters, Project Runway), documentaries (The History Channel, The Discovery Channel), and sundry (Expedition Africa, Mythbusters), et al. [NAFDA]


megan walker - Apr 26, 2012 8:48:49 am PDT #19129 of 23273
"What kind of magical sunshine and lollipop world do you live in? Because you need to be medicated."-SFist

Cee Lo's is the strongest as a whole, probably Adam's is the weakest.

And, ultimately, this is why the elimination process doesn't work for me. Cee Lo put together the weakest team by far and yet it makes no difference in the end.


megan walker - Apr 26, 2012 8:48:50 am PDT #19130 of 23273
"What kind of magical sunshine and lollipop world do you live in? Because you need to be medicated."-SFist

Didn't need to be said twice. Or maybe it did.

Damn you, double-clicking work mouse!


Toddson - Apr 26, 2012 8:56:16 am PDT #19131 of 23273
Friends don't let friends read "Atlas Shrugged"

ANTM had a Hello Kitty photo shoot ... dresses designed and, possibly, made by a 16-year-old on that theme. They were ... kind of cute. I'm still slightly boggled.


Liese S. - Apr 26, 2012 9:21:09 am PDT #19132 of 23273
"Faded like the lilac, he thought."

And, ultimately, this is why the elimination process doesn't work for me.

Totally agree. If they had pitted the teams against each other instead of within themselves, I think it would make much more sense. I mean, even a Top Shot format where they start out doing team challenges (compare battle rounds) and move on to individual challenges would be better. The concept of team is totally false in this show. There's never any incentive for the team to work together or for the coaches not to pick weaker contestants they can use as redshirts.

If the team had to win as a whole, even if it were individual performances and the scores tallied, it would make more sense. There's lots of ways it could make more sense.


Lee - Apr 26, 2012 10:32:58 am PDT #19133 of 23273
The feeling you get when your brain finally lets your heart get in its pants.

If they had pitted the teams against each other instead of within themselves, I think it would make much more sense.

I totally agree, but doing it the way they are is the only way to insure that all 4 judges have a reason to be there all the way through. I guess it could be set up as everyone sings, America votes, and then the lowest person/two people from each team goes home every week, but that still doesn't do much in terms of team spirit.


Amy - Apr 26, 2012 10:36:08 am PDT #19134 of 23273
Because books.

I totally agree, but doing it the way they are is the only way to insure that all 4 judges have a reason to be there all the way through.

They could mix it up, though. If one coach had lost his or her whole team, maybe there's a rule that they get to poach once. Or something.

The elims on this show are confusing, especially after watching Idol for years, which is completely straightforward.


kat perez - Apr 26, 2012 1:29:43 pm PDT #19135 of 23273
"We have trust issues." Mylar

Yeah, I really think the blind auditions are the best part of The Voice. After that, the format stops making a whole lot of sense. Still a fun show, but not a great show.

I haven't even seen Idol yet. I think it's the first time in years I've taped and not watched live. And I'm even enjoying all the contestants this year. So sad for me. It's the end of an era.


Liese S. - Apr 26, 2012 1:37:40 pm PDT #19136 of 23273
"Faded like the lilac, he thought."

Yeah, I know there isn't any way to keep it blind, but I wish there was.


kat perez - Apr 26, 2012 3:29:43 pm PDT #19137 of 23273
"We have trust issues." Mylar

AI performance night thoughts:

WTF, JLo? Just, oh my word. I cannot even describe the fug of those pants. Glittery golden pleated skinny leg high water pants? Go change immediately. Or no, don’t change. Let this be a cautionary tale for big booty girls everywhere. Even your cute apple bottom cannot save horrendous pants.

Queen Songs

Medley. Ummph. They sound really good on the beginning of Fat Bottom Girls. Phil was the total weak link on his line in Another One Bites the Dust. Elise and Skylar owned the boys on that song. Neither Holly nor Jessica have the grit to be convincing on We Will Rock You. And the most boring version of We Are the Champions ever? Why yes, I think maybe so. Fashion medley: Skylar looks adorable. Jessica looks like she’s trying out for her school production of Pocahontas. Holly is the best dressed teen hooker in her brothel. Elise is wearing a robe over a feather duster. Phil is in his Phil uniform. And Joshua’s clothes are still too small.

Jessica – Bohemian Rhapsody. What a predictable choice for her. And what’s with the black and white photography? That was just weird. And the three faces of Jessica behind? I mean, I get it, but why? It’s just freaky. She sounds amazing on this song, though. Is she wearing sparkly tennis shoes? Just, what? Somebody take the crack pipe away from the wardrobe people. Sad that I have time to focus on the state of her shoes because I’m so bored by the performance. Agreed with JLo that she lacked oomph. More performance quality, robot child. Be all about that.

Skylar – The Show Must Go On. Huh. Interesting choice. Too bad she’s not doing the version from Moulin Rouge. I think that may be my favorite version of this song ever. She sounds great here, though. I think she’s getting less nasally all up in her nasal, y’all. I really like this girl. The end was a little shout-y and I’m not sure whether she was having problems with her breath control or what but the notes were kinda cut off. But overall, well done. She is a comer.

Joshua – Crazy Little Thing Called Love. Alright, Mantasia. Time to stop biting. Why must the black people always choose this song on Queen night? Is it in the AI bylaws or something? Well, I suppose it was fine. The staging and the way he attacked it put me in mind of the Bruno Mars song he did a couple weeks ago and so made this performance feel like a retread, but that said, he sounded fine and he seemed like he wa having fun. It was a little too shout-screechy for me at the end, but it was fun. Good job from him. Still not as good as the Fantasia version. Side Note: Why are this fool’s clothes so small? Damn you, Tommy Hilfiger. Damn you to hell.

Elise – I Want It All. She sounded great here and I’m liking the tambourine kinda gypsy woman vibe she was working in her performance. This was one of her best and most complete performances to date. She was totally comfortable and in the zone. She looked like she was having fun for the first time in weeks.

Phil – Fat Bottom Girls. Surprised they used it in the medley if Phil’s gonna do it, too. But really, what other Queen song would he have done? It fits. I guess he did his Phillip Phillips-ian thing. He’s sounding less and less like a Dave Matthews copycat these days. Perhaps he’s finding his own authentic sound and style more, which if so, I’m all in favor. I enjoyed that but I wasn’t blown away. It was just fun. Oh, god. I’m agreeing with JLo and Randy more and more these days. That ain’t right. Hollie – Save Me. And in the pimp slot, too. Huh. Horrible necklace. God. It burns the eyes. And is this performance really pimp slot worthy? Again, I say huh. She performed half the song looking down at her feet and the other half with her eyes closed. The judges were bored and I was bored, too. And JLo is way too into being this child’s therapist. I feel like I’m eavesdropping on her latest session. Blah. Send this girl home (continued...)


kat perez - Apr 26, 2012 3:29:46 pm PDT #19138 of 23273
"We have trust issues." Mylar

( continues...) already.

Contestant's Choise Songs

Jessica – Dance With My Father. Sounded lovely. Looked lovely. Bored to tears. Poor robot child. And now the judges are giving her the “So glad you came” soft pedal. Wah-wah. Skylar – Have no idea what this song is, but it brought the nasally back with a vengeance. I’m assuming the song is called Tattoos on This Town. I shall call it that regardless. It’s a tedious song, whatever the name. She’s better than the song, for sure. Horrible choice but she sang it well. Randy, you did not make up ginormous. For real? Why is he such a tool? Oh, Steven, just say it. The song was crap.

Joshua – Ready for Love. Wow. Great song choice. And not at all what I would’ve thought he’d choose. Fire! That was my favorite Joshua performance of all time. That was spotless. I can’t even hate. Take off the scarf. OK, I can hate a little.

I would love it if Elise were the one doing DMB, but I’m guessing not.

Elise – Do these kids hate her? I mean that clip package was kinda . . . hmmm. Have no idea what this song is. I guess she likes it. Some of the notes are a little bit tortured. Not everything needs to be a run. I couldn’t even tell what some of the words were supposed to be. JLo is lying and Steven is right. Young kids won’t vote for that song. And I’m agreeing with Randy again. God dammit. But she did try to do too much with that song. I just wanted to hear a few of the notes sung straight on. Just a few.

Phil – The Stone. Sigh. This is so expected and such a step backward in my opinion. Dude has to know that everyone under the sun thinks he’s a Dave Matthews wannabe. And so now he does a Dave Matthews song like Dave Matthews. I just don’t get it. He sounds like a guy in a DMB cover band and that is not the impression one would want to give. JLo cannot have it both ways. Phil’s song was too obscure but Elise’s song was fine? Whatever. Julianne Hough sighting. What?

Hollie – The Climb. I love this song and I don’t care who knows it. Best shower song ever! And she sounded really great here. OK, I see now why she got the pimp slot. And she looked better than normal, not like your 90 year old grandma if your 90 year old grandma shopped at Forever 21. Every once in a while the light shining on her legs made it look like she had on pantyhose. I hope for her sake that’s not true. Not with peep toes. By far, her best performance ever.

Top 2 (by far)

Joshua

Skylar

Middle 2

Phillip

Hollie

Bottom 2

Jessica

Elise

I think either of those bottom 2 could go this week. Elise has been teetering on the edge for a while now and Jessica is just so overly programmed. She needs a Brit Brit style, shave the head break down. It would make her more human.

Also, SYTYCD commercial. EEEEEEeeeeeeeeEEEEEEEEEeeeeeeeeEEEEEEEEeeeeeee! I'm a little bit excited.