Yikes, it is soon. I can take Bitches, Natter and Previously.
Of course, more if needed.
'Life of the Party'
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: ita, Jon B, DXMachina, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych
Yikes, it is soon. I can take Bitches, Natter and Previously.
Of course, more if needed.
Thanks Laura!
Wow, Jon's form looks great! I'll look forward to voting, soonish!
OK, am I the only person besidse Liese who isn't sure why consensus has been largely unacceptable? Are there specific incidents I'm unaware of? A whole bunch of them?
I can put the APB in Spoilers, and both spoiler light threads.
Should I do that now?
That would be great David!
Trudy-- I can answer with my opinion in about 2 seconds when I am done posting!
Have you followed the whole discussion Trudy?
The problems with consensus have been: whoever happens to be in the thread at the time forms a consensus. The big problem was the movie thread. Two times it was raised, discussed and dismissed. On the third time, the people who raised it all happened to be in agreement and so the thread went forward. There is some sense that these consensus type decisions are really not expresssing the majority viewpoint and have become arbitrary.
Another example, is the continued raising of the issue of a Politics thread. There is no process currently in place to consider an issue, discuss it, decide on it and put aside. It got to be very wearying returning to the same issues and hashing them out again.
Those are two quick examples.
OK, am I the only person besidse Liese who isn't sure why consensus has been largely unacceptable?
I think that people have been complaining that what looks like consensus is really just a bunch of people, but by no means everybody, agreeing on something at the same time, so that it's just whoever's on the board then who determines the "consensus." I don't know what the specific examples are, though.
I've posted the APB in Spoilers, and Buffy and Angel Light Spoilers.
Did post in Bitches, Natter, and Previously.
Trudy - I don't think that many of us have been unhappy with consensus; I thought it worked. The more structured discussion and voting method just makes for a more focusey way of dealing with decisions. The comfort of structure.