Umm not not referring to the help thread - referring to your comment of being "anti-thread proliferation". I was making an argument for leaning towards a pro-thread proliferation policity , especially if we can spin off parts of Natter. Basically Natter has grown too big to keep up with and iwll get bigger. If we want it to be useful, we may need to split into general Natter and some topic oriented Natter threads - such as makeup/body care/hair care, clothing+costumes+accessories, politics/social issues, film, general TV (any TV not covered by specific threads). We can probably come up with others. Maybe a job-talk thread. The point is to split Natter into enough threads so that a person with a life could keep up with one or two and skip or skim the rest.

But I am in favor of Tape Fairy thread, over and above my general argument , just because the need is frequent enough that such a thread would be useful.

Original Thread On Semi-Spoilers and What They Are. Anyone have a good summary?

Unfortunately, a summary of that thread would be "We kind of started thinking maybe there should be a clear policy but got sidetracked by nattering about Plei's boobs and then we moved here."

I'm very much against category specific natter. Yes, it's fast, but it's natter. The point is that it's not categorized.

Great -- tell me when you have a task force and a statement of direction. I'll help you with the project plan, if you'd like.

First off, we'll need a quality policy and a set of quality objectives, and...

Have I mentioned that my current work project is upgrading our company from ISO 9001-1994 to ISO 9001-2000? So much fun and excitement! </sarcasm>

Unfortunately, a summary of that thread would be "We kind of started thinking maybe there should be a clear policy but got sidetracked by nattering about Plei's boobs and then we moved here."

I think that we had a general idea before that, though.

The point is to split Natter into enough threads so that a person with a life could keep up with one or two and skip or skim the rest.

And make those of us with no life have our heads explode.

Seriously -- I'm going to own up to having been an opponent of the initial natter thread, and then within short order being the most prolific natterer. But you know what? Natter means more traffic. Because nattering still does happen (and will continue to) in every other thread.

Moving makeup over here, and TV over there will make more volume, as opposed to about the same amount better organized. I think the organic nature of natter demands it.

Also, I don't like to think too hard when I natter.

I like the way that one topic in Natter leads to another and another and another. I'm interested in lots of things. I don't want to have to subscribe to six different threads to talk about all of them.

Anyway, here's what was said usefully before the conversation devolved:

Main casting and things that are easily stumbled across in the media are fine. Promos and interviews mostly fine. Special guest should be white fonted. Themes OK, exact plot points and widgets not.

I think the sticky point is going to be on what makes up an "exact" plot point.

(And I'm anti-thread proliferation, especially Natter. Thread-drift is what makes Natter interesting, and keeps it going, which won't work if people are constantly saying "but maybe we should take this over to Shoe Natter.")

Unfortunately, a summary of that thread would be "We kind of started thinking maybe there should be a clear policy but got sidetracked by nattering about Plei's boobs and then we moved here."

Yep. For instance, looking at the thread, post 1 just mentions vague interviews as being ok, while post 9 expands it to information that's 'widely available'. (I'm already on record as preferring the former def'n. IMO a heavy spoiler remains a heavy spoiler if Joss himself takes out an ad in the NYTimes to announce it - it's a matter of content, not availability.)

Further thought: different people are going to have different spoilage tolerances. Can I suggest that anything whitefonted in the spoiler lite threads also carries some comment to give people an idea of to what the spoiler relates (eg 'casting spoiler')?