Well, I'll concede that TB is not Masterpiece Theater, that the supposed main characters, Sookie and Bill, are mild to moderately annoying much of the time, and that the MaryAnne story line was not all that. Nonetheless, I would put True Blood firmly in my quality teevee column. They have some of the best supporting characters going. Jessica and Hoyt, Eric and Pam and their whole Fangtasia Empire of Evil (yes, I'm including Mr. Chow!), all the Merlotte's crew - Sam and Arlene and even Tara (though she sometimes grates) and of course the magnificent Lafayette. I need a special sentence just for the brothers Bellefluer, Terry and Andy, because they are so beautifully damaged. The show did one of the great reclamation projects of the 21st century in taking Jason Stackhouse from a cartoon of a porn star in a cartoon porn movie to an actual human being whom I now love and want to protect at all costs from everything that would harm him, even himself.
They have had some interesting storylines. Thankfully, the MaryAnne business is not representative of what the show can do when it's good. Tara's not my favorite character, but the season one storyline about her mom and Miss Janette and the casting out of evil demons was quite well done and kind of heartbreaking. I really loved the early story of Sookie's gran and her fascination with Bill. I liked the Tam/Sara relationship S1 and miss it still. Even though I got tired of the nekkid Jason very quickly S1, they still managed to grab me with what happened to him and Amy and vampire Eddie. (Stephen Root, y'all!) And Eric's appearances were fun, if all too brief in S1. And there's always Lafayette. Yes, Lafayette is always fabulous. Bill and Sookie are kind of annoying, but the stuff with her uncle was touching. Much like S2, the main mystery around the Bon Temps serial killer was probably the weakest story of the season.
In S2, I thought all the secondary plots were top notch. Jason and the Fellowship of the Sun? Awesome. Eric and the Dallas vamps and Godric? Awesome. Bill and Lorena? Well, maybe not awesome, but very good. Hoyt and Jessica's tragic romance? Oh my stars, awesome! Terry and Arlene and her teacup humans? Yes, I believe they were awesome. I love Terry and his special lady. The tragic fall and fall of Andy Bellefluer? Awesome. Pam, Eric and Lafayette and the wages of sin, or V, or something like that? Do I even need to say it was awesome? I mean, I guess some of the secondary plots were clunkers. Anything with the Queen, I didn't enjoy and the Evan Rachel Wood creature is mystifying. I don't get the appeal. I didn't care all that much about Eggs and Tara which is making her a little bit tough to take just at the start of this season. Sam and Daphne didn't thrill me, but that just might be because it was tainted with MaryAnne juice. But overall, I found S2 to be quite good. And I have high hopes for S3.
The show does really well with character development, maybe not as well with the big season long arcs. I don't know that I'd call it mindbendingly innovative, but I'd say it's a quality show.