Just to reiterate, I was responding to what Raq said about her step-sister:

My step-sister, who has a PhD in English, just said that The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo is the first mystery she's ever read.

As I'm sure she hasn't spent her whole life as a PhD candidate, that surprised me, since I assume with a doctorate in English she *is* a big reader, and has been for a while. I wasn't specifically talking about what she read while working on her PhD.

I'm not a big fantasy or science fiction reader, but as someone who loves to read, I *have* read one or two over the years. Same way Jess said she doesn't really like or remember mysteries, but she *has* read one or two.

Maybe that's clearer.

I guess I just don't see Ph.D.'s in English as being that catholic in their tastes or wide ranging in their interests. It's a narrow kind of reading and the people that do get Ph.D.'s don't so much read for fun, and are primarily interested in literary history and theory.

Ph.D. = narrow but deep (to me).

...do thrillers count as mysteries? I read a lot of trashy thrillers. There is usually a mystery of who the crazy serial killer is...

Nevada Barr is mysteries, right? I've read her.

But stereotypical mysteries are not my thing. Though I did read a lot of Trixie Belden growing up! :)

See, I wouldn't assume they are a big reader, as weird as that sounds. When I wanted fluff reading in school I turned to Regency romances. Most people there didn't get that at all. Not just the romance thing, but that I'd want to read for fun. I wish I were kidding. I had lot of conversations about "books," but not about reading.

It's a narrow kind of reading and the people that do get Ph.D.'s don't so much read for fun, and are primarily interested in literary history and theory.

And I feel like you're still missing my point. As KIDS, that's what PhDs are like?

As an English grad student, I read mysteries to get the taste of Henry James out my head.

do thrillers count as mysteries?

They are distinct but related in my head. I'd shelve them together for marketing purposes, I think.

Nevada Barr is definitely mysteries.

That can't be grammatically correct, but I'm leaving it.

Speaking of grad school, I guess I wasn't alone in my crushing debt: [link]

NYU's student debt alone is bigger than the gross domestic product of 12 countries.

As KIDS, that's what PhDs are like?

I t heart Amy. I get it. Like, how could you have been a kid and never read at least one Encyclopedia Brown book. I am not a big mystery reader and even I read Encyclopedia Brown!

Maybe she is out-genreing kid's lit as not broken down into further sub-genres?

Moreover, if you had to take an survey classes, how did you do Victorian without Robert Louis Stevenson or certainly Arthur Conan Doyle (in addition and alongside, of course, Jeremy Bentham and Thomas Carlyle).