I thought he referred to "us" which I took to be a reference to the Others. I dunno

Well, Henry said that she had killed two of "us." (I believe) which is where the confusion about the second person comes in.

Well, Henry said that she had killed two of "us." (I believe) which is where the confusion about the second person comes in.

I get you now. Confuzzlement cleared.

When the Tailies were first attacked and Eko killed an Other, did A-L kill one then, too?

According to wikipedia, Ana Lucia killed an Other during a raid on the Tailies camp. She took a US Army knife off of the body:

After the tail section of the plane crashes into the water off the beach, the survivors swim ashore. *** That night, three of the adults are taken and Eko kills two of the "Others" with a rock when they try to take him. From that night on, he refuses to speak.

A survivor who identifies himself as Nathan suggests staying on the beach, and the group does so. On the fifth day, Donald dies from the leg injury and is buried. On the twelfth day, the Others take nine more, including the two children. Ana manages to kill another one, who is discovered to be carrying an antique U.S. Army knife and a list of the nine to be taken, along with their descriptions. While trying to sort out what happened, the notion of an infiltrator is discussed, as well as a proposal to leave the beach.

So, she killed 2 Others -- Goodwin and RedShirt Other #1

2 Others and Shannon. Whew.

Yes, Ana Lucia really made the most of her time on the island: 3 Kills. It's the Island Version of "Clue"

(1) RedShirt Other -- by rock/stick/bare hands -- in the Tailies Camp

(2) Goodwin - by knife -- on the trail

(3) Shannon - by gun -- near the Sayid/Shannon Love Nest

How will Jack find out he has a sister?

*If* Claire is his half-sister (and the way everything is connected, it's entirely plausible that she is), Claire could make a comment about how she never knew who her father was, but her mother always referred to him as a drunk surgeon, or something.

And Jack will think, "Oh my God! There is only one drunk surgeon on earth, and he was my father!"

I wonder if the Lostaways have clued in to the fact that they're all connected. They should undergo some mass hypnosis where they discover they all went to the same party one time.

Has anyone else read Bad Twin, the Lost tie-in novel yet? Even though it's supposed to be written as a fiction work by someone on the flight, it's a bit difficult to reconcile that perspective with the content because it clearly reflects things/speculation/theories from the show, like [the author's name being an anagram for purgatory; repeated mentions of good versus evil and seeing whether or not a person can really change; groups of isolated islands, "landlocked" islands, or closed communities appearing in the story; a mention of philosopher John Locke in comparison to science (Jack?) and religion (Eko?); a boat called "Escape Hatch"; and The Hanso Foundation, Paik Heavy Industries, and the name Widmore figuring into the plot.]

Has anyone else read Bad Twin

Sawyer was reading it just last night.