What does he mean by "1930s sci-fi"?
He made the same reference about Star Trek (TOS), which is probably a reference to 30's sci-fi like Flash Gordon. Impossible scientific wonders rather than hard science (fiction) realities which Card probably tries to adhere to more.
eta: nah, I don't buy that.
Our quiet thing at summer camp was that the counselor raised his/her hand and then the kids raised theirs -- and if your hand was up your mouth was shut.
Note that Heinlein's first sale was in 1939.
She didn't even need to convince you you were wrong, she just needed to hang on to the belief that she was right.
People like this are the wellspring of all those "Cluephone! It's for you!" jokes. so we can't just banish them from this earth. But we can call them intransigent knuckleheads every day of the week, and twice on Sundays.
Like, it's one thing to be unable to wrap your brain around an idea; but it's another thing entirely to declare that your own inability to wrap your brain around an idea causes that idea to be null and void.
Orson Scott Card? Why do people still listen to him? That dude has the biggest axe and the biggest grindstone on the block.
eta: nah, I don't buy that.
I was about to say...
Why do people still listen to him? That dude has the biggest axe and the biggest grindstone on the block.
I think you answered your own question. My question is, why do people still publish him?
Impossible scientific wonders rather than hard science (fiction) realities
I like hard science fiction, but I'm not sure how well it could translate into TV and Movies. I do like the touches of real physics that show up from time to time in B5 (ships with rotating sections for gravity, some ships that preserve momentum instead of moving like airplanes), rather than the technobabble that Star Trek falls into. I think Firefly did well in not trying to deal with the science of space travel.
I think you answered your own question.
Wait, people out there actually enjoy repetitive whining??
Shoot, I could get myself paid for that.
I think original Trek was cheerfully illogical, and I enjoyed it in all of its clunky, mod, metaphorical glory. TNG was apologia for the American concept of empire. The rest of them, I don't know, although everything outside of DS9 seemed not to have a unifying theme at all.
Question:
My new loveseat is being delivered tomorrow!!!!
I love my friends for this more than I can say. I love them. I'm writing loveseat haikus.
What's the appropriate tip for the delivery guys? It's an $85 delivery charge, do I tack on 20% and divide it between the two? Give each dude 15%? Hand each dude a twenty?
I'd say $10 each if they're just delivering, $20 each if they're putting it together.
The so-called Texan Beef Chili I got for lunch has a distinctly Cincinnatian flavor to it. I am pleased.