From the link:

S3, S4, S5, S6, and S7 had some of the most ground-breaking, controversial and envelope pushing episodes in tv history.

In TV history. And this person thinks Mark seems naïve?

Heh, I was confuzzled by that statement as well. Mostly by her extensive list of episodes, including ones in S7 I didn't even recognize because I barely remember that season or individual episodes.

Passion is up. It pretty much did to him what you'd expect.

I do feel bad for Mark. Becoming 2 is going to fuck him up. As well it should.

Ooh, yeah. Because he REALLY hates Angelus. He's right there with the characters. Enter: conflicted feelings!

Also, one of the commenters posted this lovely fanart. (She fell HARD for Jenny.)

P-C,

I suddenly have this terrible premonition of how enigmaticscully is going to respond to Tara and what happens with her.

veering between incandescent rage and uncontrollable grief

I will never ever get over this.

I have done a commendable job of not throwing them out of the window today, I might add.

Okay, I cried during the soccer warmup scenes of Bend It Like Beckham. I can't talk through The Warrior or The Hunger Games or The Body without choking up visibly and audibly. Ianto should never have fucking died.

But why do I feel like a) I overidentify and b) this poster could do with some tighter boundaries?

Hey, you know, maybe their life is richer than mine because of how they consume fiction. I shouldn't judge. But I don't think I could be that much of a raw nerve. I don't think I could let anyone I don't know (or teams of clever and perceptive people I don't know) get that deep a line directly into my heart. And I generally think threats of violence towards creators, however metaphorical, are creepy as all fuck.

It still weirds me out. But, Mark Watches is the perfect place for them, because that's what it celebrates. I just can't have that relationship with fiction.

Although, Ianto, joke's over. You can come back now. Very funny!

I suddenly have this terrible premonition of how enigmaticscully is going to respond to Tara and what happens with her.

Yep, that's our next worry. Well, we've all been worrying about Joyce from the get-go. Mark really loves Joyce. I think because his own mom was terrible, he's really latched on to her.

But I don't think I could be that much of a raw nerve. I don't think I could let anyone I don't know (or teams of clever and perceptive people I don't know) get that deep a line directly into my heart.

I vividly remember how it felt to get that emotionally invested in a character or a work of fiction, and feeling just tormented by the loss or deaths of characters I loved. ROTK did it; Serenity did it; and, to a somewhat lesser extent, so did the end of the second season of Doctor Who. It wasn't true grief, but I have certainly felt depths of emotion for fictional characters that went beyond what is probably a normal reaction. It's been a while, though, and I'm not sure whether to attribute that to mere growing up, or falling in love or experiencing grief in the real world, or what. And I don't miss it -- there were times when it weirded *me* out to be so overinvested in my fictional worlds, and I'm generally happier now putting that energy toward relationships with real people. But maybe those reactions served a purpose at the time?

All that to say, I can absolutely see where that person is coming from.

And I generally think threats of violence towards creators, however metaphorical, are creepy as all fuck.

100% agreed.

I don't know how to properly articulate how this (and other) expressions of reactions to fiction can disturb me. I think there's some sort of an air that this shouldn't happen, that fiction isn't for this, that the writer did something wrong by evoking a deep grief, that this is *bad*. The reaction that you've been betrayed by the creator, that they've done something wrong...that's the part that gets me the most.

I mean, fuck, I watch Supernatural on purpose, you know? But I think it's Eric and Sera's job, just as it was Joss's to get me happy and sad and conflicted and all of those things. However, there are boundaries around it, and it's always through the lens that they're fictional, even as I cried my way through whatever book or movie. If I'm going to get mad at anyone, it's at me. Joss is not God, and he has no responsibility to care gently for his creations. I know that. It's part of why I'm there.