I'm sorry, dad. You know I would never have tried to save River's life if I had known there was a dinner party at risk.

Simon ,'Safe'


The Great Write Way, Chapter Two: Twice upon a time...  

A place for Buffistas to discuss, beta and otherwise deal and dish on their non-fan fiction projects.


erikaj - Mar 22, 2005 8:35:43 am PST #747 of 10001
Always Anti-fascist!

wrod.


Lyra Jane - Mar 22, 2005 8:38:23 am PST #748 of 10001
Up with the sun

This is about a character in what I would call my WIP if it existed much outside my head:

"Ainsley's Purse"

It almost looks like a real Vuitton, but inspect the seams and you can tell it was $10 from a street vendor. Inside, the gummy pacifier she keeps thinking her daughter is still young enough to need nestles next to her passport, marked by previous escape attempts and carried in the hope of another, among a chaos of Stila cosmetics. Her pills, obtained with feigned complaints of back pain, are in a side-zipped pocket, alongside a silver iPod mini loaded with '80's pop. The wallet bristles with credit card receipts and phone numbers, but holds no money at all.


Connie Neil - Mar 22, 2005 8:45:40 am PST #749 of 10001
brillig

marked by previous escape attempts and carried in the hope of another

neat


Lyra Jane - Mar 22, 2005 9:06:11 am PST #750 of 10001
Up with the sun

Thanks, connie.

And (while I'm feeling bold) here is a companion piece, about Ainsley's sister.

"Abbey's Purse"

It's a black canvas tote bag, so basic as to be invisible. Mostly, it has her niece's stuff in it -- a stuffed rabbit sticky and purple with grape juice residue, baggies of pretzels and raisins, a stray juice box, barrettes, baby wipes and a pair of toddler-sized underpants. A separate compartment holds all that is Abbey's -- a dogeared Douglas Adams paperback, cherry chapstick, $17.63 in change and small bills, an expired student ID, keys (also sticky). The tape of her songs lives in her inside jacket pocket, waiting for the right moment to be shared with the world.


Pix - Mar 22, 2005 9:54:19 am PST #751 of 10001
We're all getting played with, babe. -Weird Barbie

Thank you so much for the reaction to the drabble. It just...happened. And it is as poignant and frightening to me as it is exciting.


Beverly - Mar 22, 2005 10:48:02 am PST #752 of 10001
Days shrink and grow cold, sunlight through leaves is my song. Winter is long.

Lyra, yours are very evocative, and I want to know moremoremore, now!

Kristin, yours is wonderful, even if I didn't know the background. I love this:

two three-ring binders, bulging with theft and midnight oil

beyond reason, but I think that this

a gold-lettered plaque, covered in dust and accolades

Would both scan better and leave the reveal for the end if you swap the nouns:

"covered in accolades and dust" since the accolades came first, and have been covered by an accumulation of dust. Just my take. Effective, either way.


SailAweigh - Mar 22, 2005 12:18:58 pm PST #753 of 10001
Nana korobi, ya oki. (Fall down seven times, stand up eight.) ~Yuzuru Hanyu/Japanese proverb

This one ended up being more than 100 words. I just couldn't pare it down without doing harm to it (in my mind.) That said, an offering on the current challenge:

What Dreams May Come

It was, sadly, his last one left. He thought about what had gone into the making of it as he held it in his hands, fragile and amorphous. The strands that made up the mass were gossamer fine, shining like white gold but with the tensile strength of hardened steel. Fathomless black holes revolved around the gemstone center, green sparks striking off it’s surface. Deep in the heart of the emerald, slept a kernel of hope. All that was required to complete this project was the fires of creation. He had crafted this one with great reluctance, but it would be a necessity if things were to continue as they must . “Sleep well, Daniel,” he whispered and tucked the dream back under his voluminous cloak for safety.


Susan W. - Mar 22, 2005 12:42:27 pm PST #754 of 10001
Good Trouble and Righteous Fights

I'm in the process of starting a new critique group--we're trying to figure out the logistics of when to meet and so on. And while I'm already in one writers group, this is the first time I've gotten in on the ground floor and had a major voice in determining how something like this works. We'll probably end up doing a lot of our critiquing online just because of scheduling and because 2 out of 4 of us have small children, but we'll try to meet when we can.

To me, the obvious ground rules are as follows:

1. We want to encourage each other to keep writing, so therefore we'll make sure to point out the positive in each other's work.

2. We also want to help each other improve and ultimately become published, so we'll be honest and constructive, not pretending something is just fine when it needs work.

Anyone got any best and worst critique group experiences or advice on what does and doesn't work?


Amy - Mar 22, 2005 12:56:45 pm PST #755 of 10001
Because books.

More good drabbles!

Connie and erika, those were great.

Kristin, I love yours -- and it has your sense of poetry, which is just beautiful.

Lyra, those are fantastic -- the contrast is great. I'd like to meet them both. One thing I've always wondered -- how do you pronounce Ainsley?

Sail, that's lovely -- I want to read it again.

Anyone got any best and worst critique group experiences or advice on what does and doesn't work?

Personally, I think it helps if the person who is being critiqued asks specifically what they're looking for -- does the dialogue work here, for instance, or do you believe in this villain's motivation? Overall critique, aside from other pointing out stuff they love, can be difficult because I've found it leads to people wanting to you to edit/rewrite your work the way they see it -- they want more action! more romance! more description! a different subplot! which can be confusing, especially if it's all contradictory. But that could be just me. And I don't know how you legislate that, unless you make it clear that each person submitting should let everyone know they're looking for input on Element X.


Beverly - Mar 22, 2005 1:09:22 pm PST #756 of 10001
Days shrink and grow cold, sunlight through leaves is my song. Winter is long.

Amy's points are all good. I've been lucky in my groups, but they all seem to devolve after a point in time. The last one just fizzled, and I can't seem to work up a good enough head of steam to start looking for another one, or to try and start one. Plus, I've never had a group devoted to long fiction. The ones I've been part of couldn't handle episodic stuff. They seemed to need poems or short pieces, fiction or non-, that the discussion of could be completed in a single meeting.

Sail! I love that. It needs a whole story around it, right now, please. Get on it, okay?