I think Kate's crime(s) had to have been pretty serious. She'd been on the run for quite a while by the time she went back to Iowa, by the look of things, and the police still cared enough to stake out the hospital. Plus they sent a Marshal to Australia after her, which doesn't seem like the sort of thing you do for a run of the mill bank robber. Also her mother's freak-out doesn't bode well.

And yes, I do want Kate to turn out very bad indeed, and am twisting the available evidence so I get what I want. Don't judge me.

Kate did something before the death of the ex. Why would she run/change her appearance/etc. before even going to the hospital otherwise? Also, when at the hospital, she ran. She didn't do anything to her mom.

I think while she feels bad and responsible for the ex's death, that's not her big bad thing.

heh! x-posty with Jars.

I guess I've just lost faith in the writers to give us something worth waiting for wrt Kate's crime. Sure, there's all this peripheral evidence that it happened, and that it was bad, but nothing about her makes me believe it.

And then last night, with the whole "crime I supposedly commited" or whatever the line was....I have a horrible sinking feeling it's going to be like watching the OC all over again.

[eta: OH, and the hair-dyeing scene made no sense, if she was trying to disguise herself, because she's quite clearly a natural brunette. If she was trying to be incognito, she should have stayed blonde or borrowed one of Sydney's wigs or something. I mean, no wonder she got caught.]

just saw:

actually , I was interested in the Kate story -- she really seems like someone that has never grown up fromm her abusive background. I am positive she killed someone that was a buseing - and possible hurt more than that person. Maybe she killed a younger sibling to save them. I also suspect that once she killed - she kept killing . But Tom is the person she killed - because she saw him as a person. I don't mind the speculation this is giving me.

Sun is going to blame Kate for Kate's suggestion - Sun seems willing to take responsibility for her own actions.- she is paying the price for them now.

I love that Hurley is the voice of logic and reason " how am I suposed to keep straght who knows what secrets?"

Don't think the raft will get far.

Well, in fairness, the marshall did say waaay back in the beginning that he believed she didn't do it. But even if she didn't do whatever the big fat exciting crime was, she's since robbed a bank, been a fugitive from justice, shot a whole bunch of people, and endangered any number of lives. So the 'supposedly' kind of ceases to matter at that point, I think. She's going to jail, innocent of the big fat exciting crime or not.

I think there is a whole redemption theme going on her - and that is why they are all on the island. So somehow , they all gotta be able to be saved.

She's going to jail, innocent of the big fat exciting crime or not.

So? She's still more a victim than a criminal, and to me, that's boring writing. Isn't there anyone on this island without a tragically sympathetic past?

Isn't there anyone on this island without a tragically sympathetic past?

Maybe Scott and Steve were tax cheats.

Maybe Scott and Steve were tax cheats.

I got sympathy for that.

Isn't there anyone on this island without a tragically sympathetic past?

So far just Rose, Vincent and Snicker-bitch.