Jayne ,'Safe'
[NAFDA] This is where we talk about the show! Anything that's aired in the US (including promos) is fair game. No spoilers though -- if you post one by accident, an admin will delete it.
Nothing against the guy personally, but I wasn't that fond of Dan's recaps either.
Jessica, Aaron and Shack are my favorites among the lot, but Jessica's doing DH, and I don't think Aaron and Shack are doing recaps on the site any more. Oh, and I really, really liked reading Heathen's recaps for Band of Brothers when I belatedly watched the miniseries a few weeks back, but I think she's still shackled to that hospital show. More's the pity.
but Jessica's doing DH
t blink
Heh. As long as it's your DH...
<blink>
Aren't you?
Well not right now.
Hee. I just knew the DH/DH joke was sitting out there, waiting patiently for its moment.
I like Dan Kwa's recaps. He funny.
Really? I thought he was a pretty bad recapper (at least for Lost, I haven't read his recaps for any other shows).
He was new; these were his first recaps for the site. I loved his use of links, his running gags ("a bumble in the jungle!" "a grumble in the jungle!" "a fumble in the jungle!"), his dedication to recreating Shannon's crossword puzzle, the use of a table to display Michael's Good Dad Points. I didn't always agree with him, but he was both funny and creative.
Jessica, Aaron and Shack are my favorites among the lot
Shack is funny, and I haven't read much of the other two. I did like Jessica's Jack and Bobby recaps while they existed. I think Aaron may have filled in for Tru Calling once. Yeah, he did! I think it traumatized him. Besides Strega, I also love Omar. His Smallville recaps are seriously some of the funniest things on the planet.
I loved his use of links, his running gags ("a bumble in the jungle!" "a grumble in the jungle!" "a fumble in the jungle!"), his dedication to recreating Shannon's crossword puzzle, the use of a table to display Michael's Good Dad Points. I didn't always agree with him, but he was both funny and creative.
I thought he was funnier in the first couple of recaps, but the running gags didn't hold up well to me, and although I appreciated the Good Dad Points and the crossword puzzle and such, overall he just wasn't making me laugh.
Was is Jessica who did the X-files recaps? Those were a thing of beauty, and, for the later seasons, constitutes taking one repeatedly for the team so that others didn't have to suffer. Plus, action figure theater!