I'm glad they didn't kill Charlie because he, Claire, and Hurley are the only people I like.

When Jack was trying to revive Charlie one of the things that was going through my head was "Claire is going to be so upset when she learns that Charlie's dead." My heart was breaking for just the emotional impact of the moment and the destruction of the bond that Charlie and Claire had together.

I really, really want the cave corpses to turn out to be Amelia Earhart and whats-his-name.

That would be perfect.

I will say, imagine that revival scene without Kate in it -- it's not as effective is it? Anyway, not for me. Having her there and watchign and agonizedly editorializing and shrieking made the scene that much more potent than if it had just been Miracle Jack trying to fix all his past mistakes in one moment. It was like she screamed for the whole audience, you know?

Good transformative moment, anyway. The way they all sort of clutched each other, when he started breathing again.

I really, really want the cave corpses to turn out to be Amelia Earhart and whats-his-name.

That would be perfect.

Except that they're already living on a planet in the Delta Quadrant, after having been discovered and de-stasised by the crew of Voyager. But it's OK, because Voyager really wasn't very good. So.

Except that they're already living on a planet in the Delta Quadrant, after having been discovered and de-stasised by the crew of Voyager. But it's OK, because Voyager really wasn't very good. So.

Yeah, I knew that, but that's the ep that really turned me off of Voyager, so I pretend it never happened. And even if it did, we can explain everything with a temporal anomaly. Delenn being on the island is a little tougher.

Yeah, I knew that

Hee. I figured.

we can explain everything with a temporal anomaly

They are so convenient.

Delenn being on the island is a little tougher.

I can't hear you.

I really, really want the cave corpses to turn out to be Amelia Earhart and whats-his-name.

That would be perfect.

Maybe what Locke and Boone found in the jungle was a piece of the Flying Laboratory?

Having her there and watchign and agonizedly editorializing and shrieking made the scene that much more potent

Yeah, Kate's reaction just got to me viscerally. The helpless sobs, and the way she used her hand to wipe her eyes--it was such a child-like gesture, it broke my heart. EL was really good there.

From now on, every time she starts to stare pensively out into the ocean, someone close to her should have a near-death experience to snap her out of it.

I was just looking back through the screen captures for the episode and I noticed that when Charlie was hanging from the branches they were not wrapped around the back of his neck. This would lead me to believe that he was knocked out before he was hung. Another contributing factor: his hands were not tied.