I'm really not seeing any of these characters as completely clean. Well, that might be an overstatement. Claire, maybe. Jin. Hurley.
Jin's clean? On the island, possibly, though he did attack Michael, but he's killed for the Mafia.
Walt's clean, and Michael's all right, though he's keeping Sun's secret.
Has Kate really done anything bad
on the island
? She's got a sordid past, but she didn't even kill the Marshal. Or try.
Damn, I meant Sun, not Jin. I'm stupid.
The kid seems pretty harmless so far. I have my doubts about the dog.
I really, really hope the dog is evil somehow. That would be so awesome. But seriously, Vincent has to become a plot point eventually. Why else would he be there? They gotta have big plans.
Has Kate really done anything bad on the island ?
She Frenchied Sawyer.
Dirty!
t /Lorelai
So far, Hurley, Claire and Walt appear relatively unsullied by their past or present lives, but we shall have to wait and see. Claire, like Liese said up thread, may have a secret wrt her pregnancy.
The dog was lost for awhile.
In the forest.
The spooooooky forest.
It's Dogulus.
Well, cleolinda doesn't call him Vincent the Doomrador for nothing.
Also, Claire may be OK, but I'm not sure about Claire's possibly mystical/alien/zombie baby.
I think I would prefer it if Hurley's backstory shows him as the good-natured regular dude he appears.
TWoP calls him the Shifty-Eyed Dog of Doom.
I'll bet Scott and Steve will eventually wind up murdering everybody else in their sleep. Just to get more air time.