This thread is a focused discussion group. Please see the first post below for the current topic and upcoming book discussions. While natter will inevitably happen, we encourage you to treat this like a virtual book club and try to keep your posts in that spirit.
By consensus, this thread is reopened specifically to discuss Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It will be closed again once that discussion has run its course.
***SPOILER ALERT***
- **Spoilers for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows lie here. Read at your own risk***
There can't be, like, a cat werewolf, who's a cat most of the time but becomes a wolf at the full moon, right?
...OMG.
Would you be horribly cross if that ended up being incorporated into a story I'm writing? Because I love it. I know it's straying close to Peter David's rather splendid book
Howling Mad
(about a wolf that gets bitten by a werewolf, and turns into a man every full moon), but...I do love the idea of a catwolf. Would it retain its cattish temperament? Would it wreak havoc on one's kittycat supply? Would it be wolf sized, or more modestly built?
::grin:: Go ahead.
I'd imagine it wouldn't retain much cattish temperament, since human werewolves don't retain much of their human personalities. Although, what we've seen of werewolf behavior isn't really quite regular wolf behavior, so there could be an argument made that there's some of the human coming out, I guess -- the more violent human aspects, I guess.
I'd say that the catwolf would be more cat sized. Since, judging from the movie, anyway, a human werewolf is way bigger than a regular wolf.
Speaking of cats. My re-listen of Deathly Hallows brought up the question of Cruckshanks. What happened to the bottle-brush tailed, Whomping Willow taming, friend of Sirius?
Hermoine mentions making arrangements for her parents in Australia but I don't recall what happened to the pusscat.
I always imagined that he would turn out to be an Animajus, or some other specialty creature.
I always imagined that he would turn out to be an Animajus, or some other specialty creature.
She specifically debunked that theory.
I think I vaguely remember that...which doesn't make it any less a waste. Then again, the notion of not-particularly-extraordinary beings doing extraordinary things is rampant in the canon.
Still, I _liked_ that character and feel incomplete not knowing what became of him. hurry encyclopedia.
Relistening to the final battle...especially the thunk moments of Snape's ignominious death and Neville's ending Nagini are bringing me great satisfaction.
serial:
I also feel like I understand the wandlore much more so now than on first reading. I have to say that bit just didn't come clear to me until I hear Dumbledore and HarryJim Dale, say it out loud.
I'd guess Crookshanks stayed with the Weasleys since that's where Hermione was when she skedaddled.
Speaking of cats. My re-listen of Deathly Hallows brought up the question of Cruckshanks. What happened to the bottle-brush tailed, Whomping Willow taming, friend of Sirius?
True - we really did need a line from Ginny guiltily mentioning that time when she had the accident with the crossbow.
But he's only mentioned once! And in retrospect. You'd think he'd at least have gotten an nice bow to wear at the wedding...or tripped up a couple of Ministry goons along the way.
eta:
True - we really did need a line from Ginny guiltily mentioning that time when she had the accident with the crossbow.
HA!! That would have been perfect.
But he's only mentioned once! And in retrospect. You'd think he'd at least have gotten an nice bow to wear at the wedding...or tripped up a couple of Ministry goons along the way.
This is the reason why there is cat-fic.
