And the smurfs conversation, particularly, cracked me up.
Hasn't the creator of the Smurfs agreed that Donnie was right WRT their sex lives?
Willow ,'Get It Done'
A place to talk about movies--Old and new, good and bad, high art and high cheese. It's the place to place your kittens on the award winners, gossip about upcoming fims and discuss DVD releases and extras. Spoiler policy: White font all plot-related discussion until a movie's been in wide release two weeks, and keep the major HSQ in white font until two weeks after the video/DVD release.
And the smurfs conversation, particularly, cracked me up.
Hasn't the creator of the Smurfs agreed that Donnie was right WRT their sex lives?
I saw the Director's Cut recently too. It's still just about my favourite movie of the '00s so far (well perhaps just behind Mullholland Dr ) and I'd quite happily sit through an extra 320 minutes if it was on offer, but in places it did seem to be trying to clarify the story a bit too much for my liking (along the lines of the DVD commentary)...of course, even the "official" interpretation offered by Richard Kelly is still completely incoherent, so it's all good.
BTW I saw Richard Kelly interviewed on Oz TV the other night...he's cute!
Is any of the additional footage in the DD Director's Cut, stuff that isn't included in the deleted scenes section of the DVD?
Jon, there's a whole lot of extrapolated material from the Philosophy of Time Travel book that I don't remember seeing on the DVD (and which sets out, if rather cryptically, the "tangent universe" theory of the film).
Guy Pearce, Russell Crowe, and Kevin Spacey. Goddamn, that's a great movie.
Dana speaks the truth. L.A. Confidential is fantastic.
I remember being not all that impressed with Donnie Darko. I wonder if I should give it another try.
Jon, there's a whole lot of extrapolated material from the Philosophy of Time Travel book that I don't remember seeing on the DVD
I think that stuff is supposed to be from the website.
And L.A. Confidential does indeed rule.
What I don't remember about the Smurfs is where the kids came from. I know there was an origin story, but I have no idea.
See, I feel like I understood the movie, except for where the engine came from, as it seemed like it got sucked back in time, but if you don't tangent, then there's nowhere to get sucked back from, if that makes sense (about it not making sense). I don't know if that means it was over-clarified (on some or all points) or what.
I figured there was less book in the original.
except for where the engine came from, as it seemed like it got sucked back in time, but if you don't tangent
Donnie brought it from the tangent universe to the real universe, causing the possibility of the tangent to no longer exist.
Yeah but you're then left with a real universe is which a plane engine has appeared from nowhere, so that's still a rupture in the space-time whatever isn't it? Like, it's hard to see how what Donnie does actually resolves anything. So I prefer to think of the whole movie as ambiguous and unresolved.