Didn't Webb get who it was before the pager went off?

Even the audience did. The pager was more of a coda than a reveal.

Didn't Webb get who it was before the pager went off?

Yeah. I thought it was the tattoo that tipped him off. Or the fact that he was the one inspecting the body and saw (what was left of) the face.

ITA with David M about the shooting. That wasn't like Scully murdering an unarmed Pfaster in cold blood in Orison. Rebecca was being threatened and abducted by Simon, and Simon wasn't under anyone's control at the time. Warnings really aren't required in situations like that. Web was just, er, being coldly pragmatic about things.

I'm delurking myself to say I liked the ep, and thought it was a strong pilot. I don't have love yet for Rebecca, but I didn't have love for Buffy at first, either, and I trust Tim to develop her into someone I will care for. Having suffered through serial killer hell all the way back to Red Dragon (the novel, not that vapid movie), I'm hoping that we don't have to deal with it every single week, but the show seems strong enough to keep me interested even if that's the case. I also hope we're not going to see SID (Scully-In-Danger) eps all the time, 'cause that gets old. Thanks for the new show, Tim. Lately my television viewing has been confined to History Channel and Science Channel reruns. As others have already said, it's great to see your name up there on the screen again.

Is that Howard Gordon guy ubiquitous, or what?

It's really fun to read w watch-and-post and morning after dissection.

I'm gonna have to rewatch befoer commenting, I think. There was an Amber Alert in the middle and we lost some dialog, and I feel like I missed more than I thought I did..

Web mentioned that it was a tattoo on her shoulder - I think that's when he knew, although it took another few seconds for the penny to drop for me.

The pager wasn't the giveaway, which did make it different from that ER thing (which it also reminded me of) - the pager came after the moment of "oh crap that's HER", and the beeping just sort of brought it home. That's how I saw it anyway.

it worked for me, very effectively.

eta oy, the inevitable xpost of course.

There wasn't time for them to pull a "page again."

Didn't Web say that when they were still downstairs. Still -- the point remains -- the pager wasn't the reveal -- the setup was the tipoff.

It was predictable for Dana, and although I didn't notice the pager go off (so I didn't associate it with ER), I did get it was her, since team member not in any of the promo pics? She'll be discovered dead before the credits if there's an unidentified corpse in the house. Such is my suspiciousness.

I would like to mention that, when they went into the morgue, Rebecca pulled her hair back. I was stupidly pleased by that.

This made me very happy too. I like little, real things like that.

Webb tells him 'take care of it' and Conscience guy says something like "I'm on it" - and the look on his face was...interesting.

Sophie, I'm fair certain the line was "take care of her"

It was predictable for Dana, and although I didn't notice the pager go off (so I didn't associate it with ER), I did get it was her, since team member not in any of the promo pics? She'll be discovered dead before the credits if there's an unidentified corpse in the house. Such is my suspiciousness.

Ah. Same reason I don't let people I'm showing the Firefly pilot watch the credits.

Sophie, I'm fair certain the line was "take care of her"

Ah. That would change things. Although I kind of liked the possibilities that my version would have left open.

Hmm. I may have to re-watch, just to be sure. What a hardship.

"Take care of her, would you?"
"Count on it."

It might be "Watch out for her"