'Our Mrs. Reynolds'
[NAFDA] This is where we talk about the show! Anything that's aired in the US (including promos) is fair game. No spoilers though -- if you post one by accident, an admin will delete it.
Actually, I think the rest of the world mainly lives in the Kingdom of What's That, Some Television Show?
Which is, coincidentally, much the point we recently made when trying to get the Firefly thread back on topic. And failing, but so it goes; roleplaying The Rest Of The World was quite fun.
NovaChild "Firefly 4: Also, we can kill you with our brains" Jan 3, 2005 9:35:09 pm PST
I loved War Stories, and Out of Gas, but was a little on the 'meh' side for Objects in Space.
But, but, but...
Okay, I can see it, even if you are wronger than a wrong thing from Wrongsville, and also dead to me.
To someone who doesn't like the concept, I'm more than certain that those would be JUST as eh, feh, or meh as any of it.
I'm still in the "I'll get around to renting the DVDs at some point, probably, even though the concept doesn't thrill me" camp. So I guess that makes me part of the Kingdom of What's That, Some Television Show? in our terms.
I missed most of this discussion, 'cause I was playing with real, live buffistas who are so incredibly wonderful that I can't really be coherant about it yet. It was so much fun catching up here, though, even though it's making me late for enjoying sunny California.
It's hard for me to decide between Angel and Buffy, because I love them both so much. While I appreciate ita's sentiments on Firefly:
But if Firefly gets included, I get confused.
I have to say that there is no confusion for me. If Firefly is included in the equation (the whole Firefly, in order, definitely not as aired), then it wins every contest. I've said it before and will say it again. Firefly is the best show ever, and Out of Gas is the best episode of any series. Can others disagree with me and not feel the Firefly love? Certainly. And I'll feel much pity for their poor, misguided, tv-watching souls.
Firefly is the best show ever
See, I can't judge any show that didn't make a whole season the best ever. No matter how brilliant.
I can.
Firefly is the best show ever, and Out of Gas is the best episode of any series. Can others disagree with me and not feel the Firefly love? Certainly. And I'll feel much pity for their poor, misguided, tv-watching souls.
When I was large with the Firefly love, certainly Out of Gas was my favorite episode, and seeing Serenity last nearly killed me. But I never thought OoG was the best episode ever, of any series.
Love,
Ms Guided
I can pull 13 sequential Angel episodes I like just as much, if not better. Probably can do the same with Buffy.
However, it got blazingly out of the gate for me, so that counts for something.
I can't judge any show that didn't make a whole season the best ever.
I agree with ita, though I can't speak to this point as it applies to Firefly. I love My So-Called Life more than anything else ever televised. But even with that, I can't say it's "better" than Buffy or even Six Feet Under, simply because it never had the chance to get bad.
To me, what makes a TV show great is the way the canon stretches across years and off- and on-screen changes; the way the writers, directors and cast deal with different concepts and forms, and characters who have grown and changed.
It's a lot easier to be brilliant for 13 hours, than to be consistently great for 100.
Standard Ple Avert Your Eyes Warning
In baseball terms, this argument is summed up as Peak Value vs. Career Value when discussing Greatest Player Ever. And I think it's a useful distinction here. Peak Value, Firefly was (to my mind) as good as BtVS S3 (my gold standard). Career value? It didn't last as long to cover the kind of territory Lyra alludes to.