I'd say nearly everybody who posts in Minearverse posts elsewhere

This is true now because we're between shows and posting volume is very low. It was not true when Wonderfalls was on the air.

We're getting it early? Don't worry, they'll find a way to fuck it up so that we're a week behind.

Looks like they've already done both: Kevin "The Minearverse 5: Closer to the Earth, Further from the Ax" Apr 8, 2007 2:41:14 pm PDT

I really like the bucket threads, for the reasons that Jessica and others have stated -- it fosters more of a sense of community and helps spread the fannish love of certain shows to people who haven't given them a chance yet. I'm also in favor of the occasional single-show thread for a show with a demonstrably large following and a large volume of discussion, but I think for the shows that generate less discussion, having a few bucket threads would work really well for me.

What Kate, and others, said. Don't want the too big bucket, don't like the too small bucket, want buckets just the right size. That would be the tricky part.

Don't you think certain shows will generate talk and certain ones won't?

We can talk about any show in Natter. Only some shows generate significant talk there, though. A TV-focused thread will be different (and I think better), than TV-talk-in-Natter, in that we won't have to wade through politics, religion, cats, diets, tax returns, and shoe shopping to find the talk.

Still, I think some shows will catch on, and some won't -- just the way some shows get a lot of talk in Boxed Set and others don't.

Don't want the too big bucket, don't like the too small bucket, want buckets just the right size.

Ah ha. The Goldilocks thread.

I think Cindy's right, that the bucket won't be too big. Should we attempt to name what shows already attract discussion to some degree? Aside from shows that are already in their own threads, the dramas I can think of are:

House
24
The Unit
Without a Trace
Grey's Anatomy
Friday Night Lights
CSI
Numbers
Hustle


And then the shows either in Premium or proposed to be added to Premium: 
Deadwood
Sopranos
The Wire
Dexter 
The Tudors
Big Love
The Riches
The Shield
Rescue Me

People talk Jericho here and there, too.

I'd also like to talk about Bones somewhere.

2nd on the Bones discussion with ND.

edit: Which I'd put with House, because of the medicalness, though I don't watch any other medical-ish shows.