cereal: Do we have that posted anywhere? It should be in the etiquette or registration page.
Angel ,'Conviction (1)'
Bureaucracy 2: Like Sartre, Only Longer
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: ita, Jon B, DXMachina, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych
What's up?
Minearverse, Elena.
It should definitely be on the registration page if it isn't, because there are so many sites where VIPesque names (MrsMarsters or whatever) are fine (if a bit scary obsessive, IMHO), and I don't think the poster meant to decieve. But yeah, I see the potential for confusion.
didn't we...*cough* discuss names that might be confused with certain *cough* VIPs?
It's in the Cheesebutt document, but nowhere else except Bureaucracy 1. Here we go:
Choose your user name at your own risk. Excessive cheekiness will be kept in check. Betsy: "I think an appropriate policy would be "If you claim to be somebody famous, we'll ask you to prove it." Betsy: "Parodying other people's names (whether real or adopted) is tacky. We ask that you don't do it." ita: "Stompy Feet reserve the rights to pooh pooh any name, but we'll explain why [in private email, and ask you to choose another name]." This policy also covers potentially offensive names, like "fuckface", and names too similar to real famous people, current users, and former users.
removed as it is redundant
I remember the discussion, but not where it happened, or if it ever got formalized.
I'm not even sure if it was discussed here, or back at WX. t /no help
[also t /too slow
Yeah, I don't think it's malicious, and I also think it's distinguishable from JohnSweden, say, because one has the potential for confusion, and I don't think John's pseud does.
Stompy Feet reserve the rights to pooh pooh any name, but we'll explain why [in private email, and ask you to choose another name]." This policy also covers potentially offensive names, like "fuckface", and names too similar to real famous people, current users, and former users.
This looks like a good policy to me.
Two questions:
1. What is the "Cheesebutt document?"
2. How will we decide "too similar"/potential for confusion? I would be bummed if someone registered as Lysa Jane or Lyra J., or Lyra Jeanne, but if she thought of it on her own I wouldn't want to take it away from her. I'd just start posting entirely in ASSCAPS, or something.