I like "Well, I'm back" - it both goes well with the "Return" word in RotK as well as having a meaning of its own.
Bureaucracy 2: Like Sartre, Only Longer
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: ita, Jon B, DXMachina, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych
Me too, Nilly.
So, no "Dude, Seriously, Where's My Precious?"
Sniff. Okay, I'll live.
Aragorn is finally King, Legolas is still the prettiest, and Sam will still kill you if you try anything
Don't some people think the first part of this is a spoiler? I don't get it, 'cause books 50 years old, but I have seen people spoiler-cutting it in the movies thread.
I've never read the books, but it seems pretty well obvious that Aragorn is who they mean when they say "return of the king." I mean, it's not Elvis, right?
No, no, no. It's Sauron who is crowned king. Everyone is enslaved and/or killed, and Middle-earth lives miserably ever after.
(I think advertising alone would make it really hard to remain unspoiled on that front -- he made the cover of Newsweek in full Gondorian war-garb; and except for Sauron, he's sort of the only candidate. The question for the unspoiled will be, hey, do the Gondorians take him out back and shoot him as an upstart? Or he could die tragically in a freak chain-mail accident.)
(Just trying to keep it interesting for those who think knowing the title gives away the ending.)
Just trying to keep it interesting for those who think knowing the title gives away the ending.
Tolkien could've prevented this by simply adding a question mark. Return of the King? Maybe...Maybe NOT.
t LOTR natter
Tolkien could've prevented this by simply adding a question mark. Return of the King? Maybe...Maybe NOT.
Tolkien actually wanted to name the third book The War of the Ring, because he did think that RotK did spoil the ending, but he was overruled.
t /LOTR natter
I've never read the books, but it seems pretty well obvious that Aragorn is who they mean when they say "return of the king." I mean, it's not Elvis, right?
Not Elvis?!? Well, I have no reason to see it now.
I think advertising alone would make it really hard to remain unspoiled on that front -- he made the cover of Newsweek in full Gondorian war-garb
You'll just have to trust me when I say that full Gondorian war-garb = not much of a spoiler to the unspoiled.