I will try to briefly explain the situation on school placement.
For two of the high schools in San Francisco you have to apply like you're applying to college. Lowell (which is a high level academic school), and SoTA (where Matilda applied but was not accepted).
For the rest, you go into a lottery system. You pick as many high schools as you like and in the order you prefer.
However, the lottery is weighted with a number of "tiebreakers." The first being siblings. If you've got a sib going to one school you get bumped up to go to that school.
The second tiebreaker is significant as it heavily weights students who come from low-scoring districts and neighborhoods. By State law, SFUSD is not allowed to use race to determine placement but by weighting the districts they can give a leg up to poorer neighborhoods which would include majority black neighborhoods like Bayview/Hunter's Point, and new immigrant families in the Outer Mission.
Which is fine. There needs to be some remedy and opportunity to those communities.
But beyond that the assignment process has SFUSD putting the thumbs on the scale in a lot of ways which are not transparent. We know this because one parent did a Freedom of Information inquiry and found out the district had an active policy of moving kids from the Westside (more Asian) to the East and South parts of the City (poorer, black, latino).
So the fact that JZ and I both went to 4 year colleges is probably a factor and weight. They can't base assignment on income but they can make a presumptions about our income based on our college education and the neighborhood we live in. So it's frustrating knowing they're operating like this and it's not simply that Matilda's number didn't come up.
Because of COVID they have eliminated the multiple rounds of assignment that they usually do. So after Matilda found out she hadn't been accepted to SotA (on the same day JZ tested positive for COVID and we went into quarantine) we found out a week later that she hadn't gotten any of her to six choices for HS.
She was assigned to O'Connell, which is a vocational high school deep in Mission which primarily serves recent immigrant families. It's not a college prep HS and it's not in a safe neighborhood, and it's also not easily accessible by public transit.
We declined that assignment and waited for the Second Round. Then the district kept changing the process as we get deeper into the lockdown. Previously there would have been multiple rounds of assignment as kids who applied in the public system and also applied to private schools (or left the district) would accept or decline assignments and seats opened up.
Instead of having multiple rounds of assignment, now the district just did a second one. Again, Matilda did not get any of the 5 high schools we listed. Instead of assigning her to another school they simply left it blank. So she has no assignment now.
Going forward there are two options, which involve Open Enrollment and a Wait List. In July they will set up Open Enrollment and list any school that has open seats. That's first come first serve. However, since we know Matilda didn't get assigned to any of her schools we also know there won't be any open slots at the schools we'd be willing to take.
And SF's worst schools are in the lowest 5% of the State. (Whereas their best HS - like Lowell and SotA - in the top 5%. There's a massive range in the quality of the schools. And some are fairly dangerous.)
I can Wait List for one school and hope to get in as slots open up. HOWEVER, those assignments will probably also be weighted in some way that's another uphill climb for us.
Finally, there just isn't that much movement until the school year actually begins. Because if a kid has a good school assignment in a public school and also a slot at a private school, they tend to hold onto that public school slot as an asset until they have to make a choice.
I know several parents who are planning to send their kids to private school but want to wait (continued...)