C) A slice of any kind of cake whatsoever with chocolate frosting, because the frosting itself acts as a modifier that designates any cake upon which it's frosted as chocolate?
Obviously this is straight up bullshit. Though still more chocolate than I currently have.
My first thought would be B, but I would not be put out by discovering that it was instead C.
The answer is B, clearly.
A is the choice of all right-thinking humans. So there.
edit: And thus is another Great Buffista Argument born.
b. Cake that is chocolate.
JZ,
My first inclination is to find out more about the cake. I would assume A, but I have had some fucked up cakes.
I mean, yes, B is obviously the answer (the cake is chocolate, thus it is chocolate cake), but I'm not about to argue if someone gives me another kind of cake with chocolate frosting on top. Basically, now I want cake.
B. "Chocolate" modifies "cake." Frosting is optimal but optional, and can be any flavor, because the cake will still be chocolate.
White cake with chocolate frosting is not "chocolate cake."
Jesus Christ, I want cake now.
1 - A, 2 - C. CAKE I WANT CAKE NOW. Thank goodness the Infamous BlueJay is coming over with chocolate raspberry cupcakes.
Interesting...very interesting. So we've got 6 B's, 3 A's, 1 anything but C, and lots of people who want cake.
I actually have cake if I want it, but bullshit consensus seems to be that it is not chocolate cake. As I suspected.