what screwballs could you like, if you don't like those two?
See above
Jonathan ,'Lies My Parents Told Me'
A place to talk about movies--old and new, good and bad, high art and high cheese. It's the place to place your kittens on the award winners, gossip about upcoming fims and discuss DVD releases and extras. Spoiler policy: White font all plot-related discussion until a movie's been in wide release two weeks, and keep the major HSQ in white font until two weeks after the video/DVD release.
what screwballs could you like, if you don't like those two?
See above
Holiday has the same thing going for it that Bringing up Baby does: Hepburn and Grant. My OTC.
I love Hepburn, I just find her character in Bringing Up Baby annoying in the extreme.
Actually, I do too, megan. But Cary Grant and Baby make it up to me.
Sorry, JZ. The Lady Eve made me twitch and want to throw things.
It's no Nothing Sacred.
I do love Bringing Up Baby, though, so we can meet in the middle.
Okay, I thought Heath Ledger was a brilliant idea as the Joker before it happened, FTR. So there.
I prefer to believe them.
Third the sentiment that Hepburn plays (quite well, I do admit) a very annoying character in Bringing Up Baby. Second that Grant's comedic timing makes up for it.
A brilliant lesser-known screwball -- It's Love I'm After. Leslie Howard and Bette Davis play a famous but long-bickering stage couple who are invited to a country estate for the weekend -- and the daughter of the house (Olivia de Haviland) falls hard for Howard's character. With Eric Blore almost stealing the show as a valet.
I love Katherine Hepburn in Bringing up Baby. Her character and Cary Grant's are both very broad and cartoony to serve the plot but they commit to it totally and have a lot of fun.
Bringing Up Baby is a farce more than a comedy and it doesn't bear scrutiny. You just have to roll with the ridiculousness.
I regret to inform you that you are all freaky alien people whose brains are filled with wrongness.
I'm with JZ in general arm-flailage and muttering "but... but... it's Lady freakin' EVE!"
My favourite Grant/Hepburn is actually Holiday, but I wouldn't call that film a screwball comedy. It's too melancholic. Who was it that wrote that great piece about the appeal of Holiday on Salon? It was probably Stephanie Zacharek or Laura Miller. Or that woman whose name I'm memfaulting on who used to write a lot about Buffy. Judith someone?
I remember seeing My Man Godfrey in college (they showed classic films in the union on Wednesday nights--first time I saw Dr. Strangelove and lots of other films, too). Really liked it, and it was fun seeing William Powell in his heyday, instead of just as the doc in Mr. Roberts.