Cripes, Knightley looks like a wax figure in that photo. Deliberately so, no doubt, but creeeeepy.
Vonnie was very close.
Maaaaaan. I'm thisclose to checkin' out the IMDb. Must resist the temptation!
Sharon and HIlary--Amelia Earhart?
Ding ding ding! Sharon Lawrence played Earhart in that one episode of Star Trek: Voyager. (OK, that was a little bit evil.)
More clues:
Walter Matthau and Andy Serkis
Ingrid Bergman and Meg Ryan
Sean Connery and Denzel Washington.
Jennifer Jones and Isabelle Hupert
Just checking to see if people are paying attention on the thread.
Ingrid Bergman and Meg Ryan
Hah! In thinking through history to come up with my own I think I figured out this one (although I'm guessing on Meg Ryan):
Anastasia
Jennifer Jones and Isabelle Hupert
Emma Bovary
Wait, is the Portman/Redgrave thing coming from the school of thought that Star Wars was influenced by Arthurian Legends therefore Padme = Guinevere? If so, that's streeeeetching it, but hee, points for creativity.
ETA:
Anastasia
Yeap! Ryan voiced the character in the animated version.
Ha. No. Vanessa Redgrave did play Anne Boleyn, very early in her career, in "A Man for All Seasons." Her role is quite minor, but I just saw the movie the other day and spend a good bit of time IMDBing all the actors, so it was fresh on my mind.
Wow. I've seen A Man for all Seasons at least a couple of times yet I do not remember Redgrave in it at all. Probably because Redgrave is usually so blonde and tall and statuesque and I always think of Boleyn as small and swarthy and lithe.
How about Peter O'Toole and... Peter O'Toole (same character, two totally unrelated movies: extra point for naming the character and both movies without looking them up!)
Alec Baldwin & Harrison Ford