I remember him in Murder By Numbers, with Sandra Bullock and young Ryan Gosling. He was definitely creepy in that.

I thought the Creepy was still in full force when he filmed The Dreamers. There was a lot of sex in the movie, but none of it struck me as actually sexy.

They're all so young and awkward and posing, though, I think it was supposed to seem sexy to *them*.

The Dreamers seemed painful, apathetic. The juxtaposition of the eggs cooking? Made it seem so clinical. Out of Sight was so much sexy with just a playful stripping scene (and fantastic music). Harvey Keitel rubbing at a hole in Holly Hunter's stocking was far sexier. Sexy doesn't mean boobies showing. Even the scene from Mullholland Drive felt cold to me, mostly because I didn't believe the actresses.

I can't remember what part of Mulholland Drive is supposed to be sexy, but in a way, I can say that for Out Of Sight too--but that's because I thought the whole thing was sexy--I've never seen J Lo do anything worthy of that performance again, and Clooney had everything dialed precisely to pr0n. Those two sizzled for me, no matter what was happening.

For all teh sexy in OoS, I sometimes forget how freaking violent it was at times.

I think that for me, when it comes to sexy in a movie, I think I equate that with erotic or hot, or, for the majority, the anticipation or build-up. So, like, the dance scene in The Horse Whisperer was sexy to me. And Y Tu Mama Tambien was a good call. The nekkidness was there, but so was the physical emotion, totally sold by the actors (or, at the least, the actress).

I can see them trying to go for *movies* that were overall sexy, rather than scenes, but I think scenes might be a better measure. On that list, I'd include the scene from Witness and Costner's speech in Bull Durham (although that movie was actually pretty sexy overall, too).

Michael Pitt's default setting is set to "creepy". So he's very watchable when the role calls for him to put forth his natural-born creepiness, but is just icky and wrong when he's playing, I don't know, a romantic leading man in a travelogue ("Silk", I am looking at you.) I still remember an episode of L&O: SVU where he played a budding sociopath -- he was fantastic. His role in "Murder by Numbers" was cut from the same cloth.

I have to give it to him though -- I watched the first season of Boardwalk Empire and thought he was reasonably good in that. He gives good "morally bankrupt".

I vote this scene: [link] Careful--it is on some odd porn site which was the only place I could find it, so NSFW AT ALL. I suggest immediately putting it in full screen mode to avoid the stuff on the the side.

Oh, The Big Easy! Absolutely.