You mean beyond the outrage of Uwe Boll just existing and making movies?
t points to nose, points to Sean
A place to talk about movies--old and new, good and bad, high art and high cheese. It's the place to place your kittens on the award winners, gossip about upcoming fims and discuss DVD releases and extras. Spoiler policy: White font all plot-related discussion until a movie's been in wide release two weeks, and keep the major HSQ in white font until two weeks after the video/DVD release.
You mean beyond the outrage of Uwe Boll just existing and making movies?
t points to nose, points to Sean
When I've objected to remakes of great films (or adaptations of great books), it's mainly because I worry that the shiny new version will eclipse the old one and the current generation of moviegoers will miss out.
This is my biggest problem with all the remakes of French films. Because La Totale is way funnier than True Lies.
Better production values and English do not necessarily equal better films. In fact, they almost never do.
he had to drastically change a key element of the story due to studio influence. (See also: Suspicion.)
Oh man, is that movie ever frustrating. I think the original ending would have been more satisfying. As it is, a glass of milk steals the movie.
I think the original ending would have been more satisfying. As it is, a glass of milk steals the movie.
Milk. It does a body good. Or does it?
I'm generally not fond of remakes, especially of Hitchcock, but, considering he remade his own work, it would be hard to argue against a remake of Rebecca (which I love) when he had to drastically change a key element of the story due to studio influence.
Very true. It's just one of my top five favorite movies, so I get a little unreasonable about it.
I do think there are a bunch of films that could do with a remake, though. Bell, Book, and Candle is one of them -- you could update the story and (sorry, Jimmy, I do love you) make the leading man a little younger, and really have fun with it in ways they couldn't.
Considering Rebecca is a hell of story, I think it will be OK, so long as they don't do Manderley burning in 3D.
I do think there are a bunch of films that could do with a remake, though. Bell, Book, and Candle is one of them -- you could update the story and (sorry, Jimmy, I do love you) make the leading man a little younger, and really have fun with it in ways they couldn't.
I would love to see a remake of Bell, Book and Candle, but I am a heretic and want the ending changed. Yes, I still get angry over the "witches lose their powers if they fall in love" bit.
You mean beyond the outrage of Uwe Boll just existing and making movies?
I thought that was understood?
Rebecca happens to be my favorite Hitchcock, and I'm not sure how it could be improved. Perhaps -- but only perhaps -- by telling parts of the story that could only be hinted at, or not told at all, under the Code.
On the other hand, the basic plot of a young, innocent, even somewhat naive second wife trying to live up to the memory of the first wife? Could go in several directions.
Yes, I still get angry over the "witches lose their powers if they fall in love" bit.
Do what now? I've never seen that movie. Uggh. At least Samantha (Bewitched) never fully gave up on hers. Also, my tag seems especially appropriate at this juncture.