BSG (Dee)

Shooting is a bad way to go. Brig is a far better route. She can reveal on her turn, where as shooting will automatically put her in a resurrection ship, and her next turn can do damage. If we Brig her, it will limit what her out ability can do.

You do understand that nothing in this Crisis will involve Brigging me, right? Either Tigh gives the Presidency to someone else, we kill you, or there's a lot of cards gone. If I were a Cylon, I could reveal on my turn.

If we Brig her, it will limit what her out ability can do.

But then I would still get to keep all my cards and draw a Super Crisis. It's much better to kill a known Cylon than Brig them.

I also saw Starbucks card, and said she was human.

Yes, immediately. Whereas with me, you had to hem and haw because you weren't sure whether to tell the truth and be safe or lie and try to get me killed. Which is why I think you turned metal at Sleeper Phase.

And for the record, I didn't say you said Tigh was Cylon, just that you want to keep a human in the brig! When we need all hands on deck. Stop trying to twist my words to make me look guilty when you are the Cylon here.

Ha ha ha, I never said you said I said Tigh was a Cylon, so I don't even know what you are even going on about. You are making no sense at all, I swear. I can't even argue against this nonsense.

BSG (Tigh)

Hmm... Roslin hasn't had a chance to weigh in. Should I wait for her vote or go ahead and airlock the goofy doctor now?

Ok, sorry, first time with killing, still getting used to pros/cons of brig vs kill. See what happens when you ignore buffistas for too long.

BSG (Goofy but Human Doctor)

I know the card doesn't allow for brig/kill of Dee. I'm talking bigger picture here.

I know morale will only go down if you kill a human, which is why I am saying DON'T KILL ME!

Um, there was more, but I'm at work on the iPad, and can't recall it all.

BSG (Roslin)

I'm honestly not certain. I think both of them make a decent case for the other one being pretty suspicious. The nice thing is if we kill either one of them we get our answer, we just have the risk of the answer at the cost of morale.

BSG Unfortunately for me, at this very moment, my head is the only one on the block.

BSG (Tigh)

I choose Option 1 and execute Baltar.

off with his head!

BSG (Dee-lighted)

Hurrah! I've been getting antsy because we're nearing New Caprica and I still had no idea who any of the Cylons were, so it was nice of Baltar to out himself like that. If we have another one, I would still say Cally and Roslin are the ones I'm least sure about, but I have nothing to go on.

Oh, Baltar. You picked the wrong turn to fuck with me. (It would have been kind of hilarious if I'd been President with that Crisis. Yeah, no discussion needed!)

BSG

Baltar reveals a loyalty card:

YOU ARE A CYLON
Can send another player to the Brig

He discards his entire hand, which contained:

Consolidate Power 1
Consolidate Power 1
Investigative Committee 3
Declare Emergency 3
Trust Instincts 0
Launch Scout 2
Repair 1
Repair 2
Repair 2
Build Nuke 6

He then moves to the Resurrection Ship, where he does not receive a super crisis. Dr Baltron must now pass hiw two unseen loyalty cards to another player. Dr Baltar, to whom would you like to bequeath your remaining loyalty?

BSG

While Baltar decides that, the RSV in Sector 6 is about to get shot at:

Attack 1: 8. Viper destroyed!

The other raider moves to Sector 5. More raiders move from Sector 2 to Sector 3. Finally, the jump track advances. I'll wait until Baltron decides where to direct his loyalty cards before we start Dee's turn.

BSG (Dee-ranged)

OH GOD BALTAR WHAT IS THAT HAND I HATE YOU SO MUCH. BURN. BURN IN CYLON HELL.

Attack 1: 8. Viper destroyed!

Geez, we are so frakked.