BSG

If I go with the skill check I can only help a little. I'll pause for input.

BSG

It looks like either way we're frakked, card-wise. The skill check is pretty high (we just failed a lower one), and we'd probably have to burn at least 2 cards per person to have a shot anyway (except for Cain, obvs, who can only help a little as it is). Even if we pass it, Cain only gets to look at one Loyalty card, so even if she does pick the right person, she might not actually pick the Cylon card (this would have an easier choice before the Sleeper phase, when we could have found out Boomer), and that would have been a colossal waste of cards. My Cylon Detector looks at ALL Loyalty cards and comes with a 100% money-back guarantee.

Or we discard two cards (at least we get to choose them) and pick up Treachery (and give Boomer more Treachery), which is also bad. But I think we'd end up losing more cards in the skill check when you take into account interrupts and whatnot.

BSG

I can only help a little because I wasted that SP. Again I say, harumph.

In other news, yes, someone definitely did spike the last check. I excluded destiny for that reason, to discourage a spike or at least to make it clear, and it's clear. Boomer spiked with Treachery; she's the only one who drew it. All the rest of us draw green, so it could have been anyone. Cally & I both played two cards, so we would have been offsetting ourselves, although that's possible.

By the numbers, it's most likely to be Baltar, who is now offering to check loyalties, hmm. I had suspicions of him before the halfway point; and now that Boomer handed him the rest of her loyalty cards, well, that didn't ease my mind any.

BSG

By the numbers, it's most likely to be Baltar, who is now offering to check loyalties, hmm.

It's what I do! Are you really going to blame me for wanting to use my OPG, especially now that we've got a spiked check? Hell, I deliberately waited until post-Sleeper because someone who checks out Human pre-Sleeper could be Cylon post-Sleeper, and then my OPG was not as useful as it could have been.

I had suspicions of him before the halfway point

I'll admit I made some bad decisions (GODSDAMN YOU BOOMER), but I assure you they were not intentionally bad.

now that Boomer handed him the rest of her loyalty cards, well, that didn't ease my mind any.

I'll admit that having five Loyalty cards makes me a prime suspect, but—and this is P-C speaking—in the first game I played, I ended up with four Loyalty cards that all said NOT A CYLON. And this time I have five.

BSG

It does seem to make the most sense that it is either Cain or Baltar. If it was one of us who played two cards then due to the values on the cards it would have only been a net negative value of 1, which doesn't seem worth it for a spike.

I can help with this skill check and it would add up to be quite a bit of help.

BSG

Centurion, bring me a vat of popcorn. This is getting interesting.

Centurion, bring me a vat of popcorn. This is getting interesting.

BY YOUR COMMAND. SHALL YOU BE WATCHING FROM THE COMFY CHAIR?

BSG

Nobody expects the Comfy Chair!

Which is to say, yes.

BSG

So you suspect Cain and me. (I'll try not to hold the latter against you. I understand why you suspect me, and I'll be reasonable about it.) If Cain's the Cylon, then passing the skill check to let her check a random Loyalty card would be...inadvisable. If she's not, you will probably ask her to check me, and since I have five cards, you won't actually believe her when she pronounces me human. You probably won't believe me if I use my Cylon Detector on her (or anyone) and pronounce them a Cylon. Which is really annoying, thanks a frakking lot, Boomer.

I'm not discounting the possibility that it's one of you, though. There was an LS-1 in there, and a net negative value of 2 isn't bad either. The intent may have been not just to spike the check but to get us squabbling like this. Now I'm confused.

The other option is, if you suspect Cain, to tank the check and brig her, but that would transfer the Admiralty and it would be bad if we were wrong about her.

BSG

I know I'm not a cylon but I can't think of how to prove it. I don't want to go to the brig and I'm trying to decide if Option 2 is worth it.