I suspect neurosis, and possibly narcissism rather than stupidity. (I use these in the popular sense and not as medical diagnoses.) I'm not saying she may not be stupid as well, but this I would put to other types of mental problem.

Most writers are probably a little bit of both. But most people who've achieved her level of success have a little bit more self-control.

Some people are going to hate her work cause girls have cooties.

Some people are going to hate her work cause girls have cooties.

Emily Giffin?

Yeah, I don't think most people that would hate her work as a rule (i.e. people who don't like general women's fiction) are going to bother reviewing it, but everyone's going to get a few readers who don't like a particular book.

To some extent, women's fiction still comes with automatic disrespect.

Right, but my point is that it's just accepted. No one bothers to protest the fact that her chick lit novel isn't up for the Pulitzer, you know? Fiction like Giffin writes is not romance, but it's not Maeve Binchy-esque either, it exists in its own little pink ghetto, and no one expects different.

Yeah, I don't mean to say she should be *surprised*

And what I was trying to say, badly, was that a lot of genres come with that immediate disrespect, not just women's fiction. Sci fi isn't considered worthy in most lit circles, and neither are mysteries.

The book world is just like high school. Which is ... just like the rest of the world, really.

::flomp:: so.tired. Chicon seems to have gone really well. My panels were pretty good, everyone else's were amazing. The writers workshop I helped run, in conjunction with a more experienced writer (Jack McDevitt) went really well. I didn't pass out or drool during my reading and people came to it. I got to pitch my first agent and picked up six new interviews for cooking the books. Yeah, totally happy. And exhausted.