I am utterly thrilled for you!
MWAH!
Willow ,'Storyteller'
A place for Buffistas to discuss, beta and otherwise deal and dish on their non-fan fiction projects.
I am utterly thrilled for you!
MWAH!
Barb! Congrats!!!
Such an excellent day for Buffista authors! Congratulations, Sox, and Barb, that's awesome. Was this at BEA, or a separate thing?
I had a big line! And we ran out of books, which was wild, but also sort of sad, because there were about a dozen people left who looked totally bummed. And so many librarians, which is thrilling. (I never really expected the romances to be acquired for many libraries.)
I'm now exhausted and barely coherent. Lonnnnnng day. Oh, and I met P-C's author friend, Mira Grant!
OK got feedback from senior editor. Need to do one more round of revisions. But the feedback was she went over two chapters and pointed out where there poor transitions, and lack of clarity and so on.
And then she told me go through the rest of the book and find where the same problems were through out. And OK poor transitions I can find. But would it be unreasonable to ask her to go through the rest of the book and point out anything she finds unclear? Because while I understand that stuff that is clear to me might be unclear to a reader, it occurs to me that pointing out where this is happening is something an editor might do. Am I misunderstanding the role of an editor?
OH and total congrats to Barb! Been a bit distracted.
Congratulations Barb! That's awesome!
Go you Amy! Running out of books is a great problem to have.
Congratulations Barb!
That's wonderful, Barb!
And go, Sox!
But would it be unreasonable to ask her to go through the rest of the book and point out anything she finds unclear?
An editor should be editing your entire book, not a representative sample. She should absolutely be pointing out which parts she finds unclear, or thinks might be unclear to a reader.
Given the conversation in Natter (on Plan B), Maggie Steifvater's two recent blog posts about the publishing industry and writerly jealousy are really timely.
The second one is the one I linked -- the first one is linked within the post.