"We're the Four Horsemen. HORSE men! Whoever heard of the Four Mulemen?!"

"Be a great name for a band, though."

"Yeah, it would."

Snerk, connie. Got a good kick out of that one.

It's the five asses of the apocalypse.

So, if a person were to enter a writing contest that says it will notify finalists in "early June," at what point should that person give up hope? Today, because only the first week of a month is really early? June 15, because anything in the first half is early? Only after the finalists are listed on the website and her name isn't there?

(I'm entered in the Pacific NW Writers Association literary contest, science fiction & fantasy category, and I'm ridiculously nervous, because it's the first time this WIP will be read by total strangers. And, they notify finalists by mail, so I can already guarantee I won't find out today. By MAIL. Sheesh. I don't get it. Not only is there this new-fangled thing called the internet, there's this downright old-fangled thing called the telephone.)

I'd give it 3-4 days after June 15th. As you said, "early June" can mean anything as late as the 15th. Since mail can take a few days, allow for that.

June 15th is Sunday. So I would keep up my hopes through at lest Saturday, June 14th.

[Update} And as sail says perhaps a few days past that as well.

Susan, I think statements like those are rough guidelines. Much the way I used to say I would try to respond to submissions within eight weeks. (It was more like six months, if they were lucky or had an agent who would call and yell at me.)

It's weird how low-information this is compared to RWA contests, where I'd almost always seen the scoresheet before entering, knew what pool they were drawing their first-round judges from, knew exactly who would be judging the finalists, etc. And since RWA is a close-knit organization, if you're on the right email loops you know exactly when finalist calls/emails start going out on a particular category.

This one? I know my entry got there and passed muster WRT formatting etc. because A) they cashed my check and B) they didn't contact me to say I'd used the wrong font or had too many lines per page or anything, and the rules said they would. I know every entrant is supposed to get two critiques, and that I gave them the proper size of SASE w/ Forever stamp to get mine. Other than that? I'm just watching my mail like a hawk. A jumpy, twitchy, anxious sort of hawk.

Susan, I wouldn't give up hope until the names are listed with a vague statement such as early June.

Huh. I think that's the association my brother in law's parents used to be active with before his dad retired from writing.

(I think both of them were on the board.) Small world!