I think this Watson will be the one who humanizes Holmes. He's the only one to draw out Sherlock's sense of humor (loved both of the laughing scenes at the end of the cab chase and the end of the show), and the way that BC plays Holmes, you can see that he needs a friend, not just a skull to bounce ideas off of.

The guy who introduces Holmes and Watson should get fleshed out. He's such a throwaway character, and he seems highly intrigued/amused by watching the two of them.

I despise the Basil Rathbone Holmes' movies because they portray Watson (and Lestrade) as bumbling idiots. Watson is the viewpoint character, our entry into Holmes' world. He represents the intelligent reader. Holmes' brilliance only sparkles in its contrast to an intelligent, capable foil. There's nothing great about being smarter than an idiot.

"The Three Garridebs" is a pretty meh story, but it does have Holmes going a bit psycho after a bad guy shoots Watson. And I can't remember if it's in canon or the apocrypha that we have the line "Never let them say you were merely my Boswell." (The canon and the--well, there's not better word for it--fanfic starts to run together. I wonder how big your name has to be for it to become pastiche instead of fanfic. Or if it's the size of the penis.)

(The canon and the--well, there's not better word for it--fanfic starts to run together. I wonder how big your name has to be for it to become pastiche instead of fanfic. Or if it's the size of the penis.)

Heh. I do love The Seven Percent Solution, which is just fanfic written by a professional author and adapted for the big screen.

Speaking of Doyle short stories, someone over at TWOP mentioned that the kid in last night's ep who goes back to his flat for his umbrella is James someone, which is a character in another SH short story who is mentioned in passing as being the victim in an unsolved case who vanished after going back to his place for his umbrella. Nice shout-out for the book fans!!

That line is from The Seven-Per-Cent Solution.

I am an Arthur Conan Doyle purist. As far as I'm concerned, everything else is fanfic and not canon.

everything else is fanfic and not canon.

Oh, true, and I've used the extra stories as an argument for the legitimacy of fanfic. There have been "undiscovered stories" for decades, and the whole phenomenon of The Baker Street Irregulars is just fanfic dressed up for scholarly gentlemen geeks who otherwise would never do "that sort of thing."

This is where I hate that my books are scattered between house and storage shed, I used to have all my Holmes materials on two nicely organized bookshelves near my home computer. I'm not even sure where my Annotated Sherlock Holmes two-set has gotten to.

everything else is fanfic and not canon.

And, indeed, not Conan.

I've got all three volumes of the Annotated SH (the two-volume set of the short stories, plus the one volume of the novels)--got them for Christmas last year (thank you, Mom and Sis). Cool thing is that, if you line them all up on the bookshelf, the books' spines form the silhouette of Holmes with his pipe and deerstalker hat.