Matt, sweet...what eyebrows?? I never got that far. It's possible if they had been sparkly purple antennae, my reaction wouldn't have changed.

GUHHHH.

Sam's kinda a top in bed! RAWR.

Does he even have eyebrows? Seriously the last place I'm looking.

Huh. I get so little chemistry from JP and GC that I ended up thinking the director was trying to hard to make the scene hot. It felt OTT. ::shrugs::

The manhandle-y totally did me in. The "I'll just pick her up entirely with one hand and move her around because I am enormous and strong like whoa" was insanely hot. I'm not usually a size-differential-kink girl, but GUH.

There were no eyebrows on his shoulders or upper back.

Also, what Jen said.

Okay, I didn't even know we had a Supernatural thread! Which, on reflection, is dumb.

I'm with almost everyone on the very hot, except that I also find Sam a little... well, always over the top, so mostly I was thinking, "Hot! ... but it would be hotter with Dean." Am I very very shallow?

I was completely grossed out by this too, but it was more that he was dirty than the fact he was dead. I just couldn't imagine having sex with someone who was covered in dirt. That just gives me the ick. I cannot believe I prioritize that over "being alive."

And, by the way, this COMM was what prompted me to come find this thread. I had the same reaction! It was kinda hot, but I kept thinking, um, dirt.

Not helping the shallow here, am I? Er... was anyone else the opposite of surprised by the angels' intention toward what's-her-psychic? It was sort of like having a convicted pedophile on CSI -- they'll try and make you think maybe it's not really him, but you know it's always him.

Maybe it's less obvious if you didn't get most of your stories about angels from Sandman and Hellblazer, but for me it was like, yes, righteous angels with their smiting and no concern for human life or morals, DUH.

I seem not to be very erudite today. Maybe I'll go have more coffee!

There were no eyebrows on his shoulders or upper back.

So much this.

Am I very very shallow?

We don't mind! We're cornering the market on it in here.

I actually find it hotter when Sam goes all bitey animal during sex. Because Sam started out so sensitive, a little shy, the kind of guy who wants to be in love with the girl in his bed, you know? And both sex scenes with Sam have been RAWR.

And Dean, Mr. One-Night Stand, complete hedonist, has (aside from the through the window thumbs-up in The Magnificent Seven) only been shown having much more tender, emotional (if, yeah, still hot) sex. With Cassie, his ex-girlfriend, at that. And with Jamie, we got sweet morning-after good-bye kisses.

Just ... an interesting difference there. Also? More skin, please! Um.

"Hot! ... but it would be hotter with Dean."

But...that would be incest, right? That does gross me right out.

But...that would be incest, right? That does gross me right out.

i'm pretty sure Emily meant it would've been a hotter scene if it had been Dean and not Sam, but i could totally be off the mark. (incest squicks me too. i don't get the whole Wincest thing at all.)