I think that logically it belongs in BS but I'm good with Minearverse. That's what Minearverse has been lately anyway. I don't think it belongs in Buffy/Angel at all.
'Shindig'
Bureaucracy 4: Like Job. No, really, just like Job
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: Jon B, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych, msbelle, shrift, Dana, Laura
Stompy Emerita: ita, DXMachina
I was under the impression that Dollhouse discussion was going in Minearverse until such time (if ever) it was decided it was generating enough discussion to warrant its own thread. I'm happy with Buffy/Angel or Minearverse. I would not be happy with Boxed Set.
As usual, I won't be able to discuss any not-airing-here show, so I'll refrain from any opinions as to where I'm not discussing it, but I'll be delighted to visit my town again with links, if that helps.
(Um, they'll have to wait until shabbat is over, though, so they'll probably be late and less-helpful than they could be, but there's no way for me to work around that schedule, sorry.)
I like the Minearverse option.
I'm using Minearverse, for the simple reason that although it's not Tim's show, his fingerprints are all over it. Also, he wrote two eps and directed one of them, and it's a pretty pivotal one. He's been working on it for months and there's nothing else Minear to discuss, too.
I'd prefer Minearverse or the Buffy thread. There's too much else going on in Boxed Set for me to really keep track as much as I'd like for a new Joss show.
I see a consensus that no one seems to want the discussion in BS (me, I'm skimming like a skimming thing in BS because I'm trying not to be spoiled for Battlestar, since I want to watch from the beginning)
I vote for B/A just because it's not getting much use, but I feel confident that it will quickly spin off into it's own thread. Frankly, I think that we're better off creating a new thread, then voting to fold it in if it doesn't get the traffic.
Frankly, I think that we're better off creating a new thread, then voting to fold it in if it doesn't get the traffic.
In this I am Vortex.
If someone came to b.org wishing to discuss Dollhouse, I don't think they'd think to look in Minearverse or B&A.
If someone came to b.org wishing to discuss Dollhouse, I don't think they'd think to look in Minearverse or B&A.
Drop it in the slug. We don't have a responsibility to newcomers to have a thread, just to provide reasonable direction to people looking for it.