Wow, they should have saved Neil and Alan for the finale against each other. Though I hope the final outcome is the winner of that match rather than Bendis or Miller.

I think I clicked on each of their names a dozen times before making my final choice.

Damn Gaiman fanboys are probably all busy doing their eyeliner for an Anansi Boys signing or something.

Neil told 'em to vote for Moore. Amazingly obedient ....

(I'm expecting and dreading the Miller outcome.)

I admit that I chose Neil, though Alan's better. Neil needed the vote more.

Well, you know, in my HEAD he needed the vote more.

(I'm expecting and dreading the Miller outcome.)

For this round, or for the whole deal?

I kept expecting someone to knock him out earlier, but that was wishful thinking.

Miller's like the Chris Carter of comic book writers in my world view: started with good and seemingly novel concepts that shook things up, but hamstrung by hubris and a belief in his own hype.

For the whole deal, sadly. Although I'd dearly love to see Bendis take him in this round.

I voted for Bendis, for the reasons Plei gave in her description of Miller.

I'm looking to the future, not the past. (Yes, I voted for Moore over Gaiman. Yes, I can see where that contradicts the whole future/past thing. Hush up!)

Yes, I voted for Moore over Gaiman. Yes, I can see where that contradicts the whole future/past thing. Hush up!

Eh, it doesn't really. They're both kind of past, but Moore's more active in comics than Gaiman.

Be glad you didn't read any further into the Village Voice review. From the second paragraph:

Gaiman's had too much success to think in any terms other than those that have earned him subliterate demigod-hood

Um. I think I'm officially pissed off at being called subliterate. I think I also have a bunch of rather advanced books on my bookshelf, right next to my Gaiman comics, that prove otherwise.

DX- Ah. Doesn't make logical sense to me, but then again, we're talking about people who do or don't have super powers based on what color a star is so I guess if it's true to the comics I just have to accept it if not like it.

Um. I think I'm officially pissed off at being called subliterate.

I read that as Gaiman's works are subliterate, not the people who read them. But it's insulting either way.