it's awfully dead(ha!) in here for there to have been a new Supernatural tonight. is it because all of the vocal people have gathered together to watch?

it was good, but certainly not one of the best episodes. Dean felt a little off for me tonight. don't know why. loved Tricia. it was nice to not see her as a manipulative sex machine.

I think that Tricia Helfer is taller than Dean w/o six inch heels. But it was nice to see Sam next to a woman who wasn't over a foot shorter than he is.

I thought Tricia did an excellent job and I loved how this episode totally felt like a horror movie.

Smallville: if I cared about the characters more, I might have had more interest in this episode. They should have gone for the cheese.

Oh, and could they have made a WORSE promo for the next episode?

Honestly, from the time Molly climbed out of the head-on collision with the tree without any blood, bruises, or torn clothing but with a missing husband and missing car, I wondered if she was a ghost. And then add the anvilicious conversations with Sam about "where do ghosts go when you kill them/when they die..." I doubted myself because of the commercials that showed her hanging and being scratched open. But I guess ghosts can hurt other ghosts.

Dean felt a little off for me tonight. don't know why.

I thought Dean was in a more than usually pissy mood tonight.

Dean's pissy, and Padalecki must have had a doozy of a sinus cold when they were filming. Poor baby.

Overall, a swirling vortex of earnest dismay, that not even Dean's nonplussed wisecracks could overcome. Although "smells like old lady" was a damned good line.

Yeah, I was much more eh about this ep than I thought/hoped I would be for the ep after a long hiatus. Both Dean and Sam seemed a little off to me.

Also, what did Dean say right after the Impala died? We rewound and rewatched a couple of times, but neither of us could hear it clearly.

I thought it was kind of a classic horror thing--isn't there an urban legend about the ghost who doesn't know she's dead? I guessed she was dead early on, but didn't make the connection that she was the one who'd killed Greeley.

I did like that they had that conversation about where ghosts go, because even IMTOD didn't really answer it.

Setting bones on fire takes a while, though--Sam really cut that close.

Also, what did Dean say right after the Impala died? We rewound and rewatched a couple of times, but neither of us could hear it clearly.

God, me neither. I rewound over and over again. Anyone catch it on CC?

We now think it was "I don't think it's going to let her go".

Or "he's". I don't think he's going to let her go.

But, yeah, that took about ten rewatches and then finally going back in retrospect to figure it out. Enunciation is really a skill, boys.

I thought he said he didn't think it (or he) was going to let her go.

I liked it, but I'm a sucker for outsider POV, which is pretty much what the episode was. The episode wasn't really about them, except when it was, and was surprisingly quiet for all that it made my skin crawl.

Is throw Dean into a wall and torture him part of the drinking game? If not, it should be.